Searching Rudolf Steiner Lectures by Location (Stuttgart): Matches

1.0c
[ [Table of Contents] | Search ]

Searching Rudolf Steiner Lectures by Location (Stuttgart)
Matches

You may select a new search term and repeat your search. Searches are not case sensitive, and you can use regular expressions in your queries.

Enter your search term:
by: title, keyword, or context
   Query type: 
    Query was: must
  
Here are the matching lines in their respective documents. Select one of the highlighted words in the matching lines below to jump to that point in the document.

Title: Lecture: The Two Christmas Annunciations
Matching lines:

Mysteries as though he must say: “Now I am living on earth; my
world must be described from within; but we must first get into the
And when we see how humanity received the event of Golgotha, we must
Golgotha became necessary. The fact of the Mystery of Golgotha must
indeed grown remote from the Mystery of Golgotha. We must become aware
It must be found entirely anew.
must take on life once more. What was once outer must be built up
mathematical abstraction; and in like manner the inner must be widened
You see, what must be taken into consideration is that in the
should look for what must be born anew in this our age. For truly,
real Christianity must be born anew. We need a cosmic Christmas

Title: Lecture: The Ear
Matching lines:

in my Theosophy. Of man, however, we must say that in many
us with our senses; nor can we say this of the human ear. Rather must
we say: To understand a human eye or human ear we must have recourse
super-sensible world. We must realise that a human ear, for example, is
Heavenly, you must add the vowels to it. But have a care! for you will
follows that the knowledge of super-sensible worlds must be attained by
the whole man. Already when we arise to Imaginative cognition we must
on spiritual science. Spiritual science, as you are well aware, must
be acquired with inner activity. We ourselves in our inner life must
do something for it, we must be inwardly alert and quick. Even then,
the whole human being. The whole human being must be living in
are most rich in feeling; and in outer earthly life it must be so. But
women. For the moral qualities must be acquired by the inner
acquire it here on Earth. As the physical eye must be acquired in the
pre-earthly life, so must the eye, for the perception of the spiritual
It is simply untrue to say that one must see into the spiritual world
as such is not the essential task of man on earth. Clairvoyance must
puberty arrives — for it must be developed by that time —

Title: Education for Adolescents
Matching lines:

must be led to look out into the world around them and into all its
piece of music, for instance. All this must be brought to them in such
world must become so all-engrossing to young people that they simply
21, you simply must not expose your latent inadequacies and so make a
inwardly, the teacher must be capable of doing this himself, so that
he can bring about such a formulation in class, and he must be able to
“stopped up.” This must and can be avoided. But it can only
You see the teacher must, in full consciousness, be permeated through
transformation of the courses one gives that the pedagogy must concern
lead young people over from the ninth to the tenth grade, then we must
the children must say to themselves: “Great thunder and
must arise. Verve is what teachers must bring to young people at this
Young people demand imaginative powers; you must approach them with
must build in the most careful way upon the fundamentally basic moral
This moral attitude must show itself in that we do not give all too
Naturally we must look not at appearances but at reality. It is

Title: Lecture: The Cosmic Word and Individual Man
Matching lines:

N present-day anthroposophical life we must begin to develop an art which
affairs, a great deal that has been lost, and must be renewed. The art I
old Mysteries, thus: from words there must be drawn Spirit. But
once more: Spirit must be drawn forth from words.
what I once described (because these things must be described in vivid
an appearance, and its true inner reality must be sought. This reality
needs this whole activity. For he must live on within it, when he has
account must be taken of what these beings of the Second Hierarchy,
Second Hierarchy is violently dislocated. And it must be restored
again. The human being must not live on after death in those forms
immoral being. He must strip them off, and find his way into the
To Beings one must come at last in all understanding of the world. For
everything. Men must understand this again, in order not to speak of
must have particular Beings. But consciousness of these Beings has
in becoming a self-apprehending being himself. He must realize again
We must understand the connection of these things. Then the particular
further, we must not only remember the Monads, but we must understand
astral body — must be brought to life, in the way we have done
human being in Willing, Feeling, and Thinking — these must be
must be formed in such a way that it can become the organ of thought,
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Awakening to Community - I
Matching lines:

practical situation prevailing in the life around them must be taken
they are honest. But we must admit, too, that the very clarity
with the life about him, as indeed he must, his real desire is to
will impulses inward, he must, in other words, strive for the kind of
us. They throw light, however, on the question of what must be done
Movement's first phase. This is a capacity one must work to develop.
long-latent conflict. It must be brought out into the open and
suffers from two evils, both of which must be overcome in the
books bring in money and appear on book lists. There must be themes
held that man was born evil and must overcome his nature, the
often nothing more than pretense. I must add that both these ominous
anthroposophical life must overcome. If this anthroposophical life is
to develop in a practical direction, everything it undertakes must be
enterprises are outgrowths of anthroposophy. This must be kept firmly
men and other such specialists simply must not turn their backs on

Title: Lecture: Past Incarnations of the Peoples of Today
Matching lines:

them in a really effective way. Again and again it must be emphasized
understanding of human life. The teachings of Spiritual Science must
working as well as the inherited physical characteristics. We must
so long as we have eyes only for a fragment of the reality. We must
essential reality. More and more we must realize how necessary it is
people, but for all that must be made known today. It is right
really to make any headway in spiritual research must be on their
must emphasize here that certain details which I have given on
What I propose to tell you today must be taken as referring to a
Universal behind the world of nature and the deeds of men. We must
which Christianity lives in the souls of Europeans today we must
repeated earthly lives and merely take it as a theory. It must be
anthroposophical Spiritual Science must not be afraid of applying to
I can accept them without having experienced them myself. But I must

Title: The Supersensible Being of Man and the Evolution of Mankind
Matching lines:

inner activity. Will must be brought into thinking, the kind of will,
natural phenomena must now be developed as a thought activity
process which must be carried out by active thinking, cannot actually
to further stages, however, we must then ascend from the level of
their thinking is not healthy enough and that they must throw off the
modern man. Modern man must work for spiritual vision in the way I
present day cannot muster sufficient inner courage for this as yet.
spiritual science as we pursue it must shake off all the reproaches
Therefore I must not pay attention to the kind of reproach that was

Title: Lecture: The Peoples of the Earth in the Light of Anthroposophy
Matching lines:

as regards the future it must be said that vague sentimentality alone
transcends the individual human element must be revealed by knowing
recognise a nation as a reality we must rise to the
on the Earth must be able to develop love not only for an abstract,
really understand their fellow-beings must develop love for the
oriental sages was somewhat as follows: ‘You must
breathe in a certain way; you must enter into the rhythm of
possession of daily life; his ideal, therefore, must necessarily
human soul and the Divine. If man's nature is to be complete, he must
he must awaken the antithesis of all that he possesses by nature.
must, in effect, develop another kind of quality — not an
peoples is not his and he must find it in them. In his heart he feels
manhood lies in every individual, but it must be brought to
layers of misconception — and these must be cleared away. Think
‘spiritual giraffe,’ must transcend the merely
in mathematical and mechanical formulae. The Westerner must realise
as a thinking being if this were not so, and he must also realise
us, but this urge must grow into a love for all humanity, for those
creations of one's own people. Each individual race must so find its
humanity; one can speak of this impulse or that. But it must be
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Anthroposophy's Contribution to the Most Urgent Needs of Our Time
Matching lines:

Intuition. Each soul must ask himself this significant question,
outlook which must necessarily extend these causal connections to
knowledge to the point where if we are consistent we must say,
all-powerful natural necessity which must be deduced from what
must include man himself, to that other order, which is moral, and
which is bound up with what man must consider to be his entire
man must find within himself a certainty of belief. He must recognise
power of the human soul and spirit, then we must come to the
preserving the realm of morality. This must be said, because the
realm of natural order. We need only consider how the thought must
heat entropy — I say expressly, must arise — that
must hold fast to the current way of thinking about natural
only including all men but with them all moral ideals. They must
leaves him in a situation where he must see the world as split
theoretical ideas. If a man intends to live honestly, he must work
soul must lead in the very near future. An answer will never be found
Inspiration, we must not only practise in a soul-spiritual way the
production of ideas which are like remembered thoughts, but we must
consciousness which has been now attained. We must practise no longer
having, yes, the unreal imaginations. We must deliberately
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Yuletide and the Christmas Festival
Matching lines:

sense must be pained by displays of so-called Christmas
of high festival in the ancient Church's year. We must learn
the highest light he must seek for it in the deepest depths
that mankind has a mission, what conception must we have of
that mission? We must conceive that man has a
physical matter, with the outer physical plane. But we must
this we must say to ourselves: as the human Ego is today,
must have some idea of the kind of life led by simple folk in
olden times. It now belongs to the past and must not be
that the Paradise Play must be performed in the mood of piety
there is no longer any indication that truth must be sought
lying before the actors must be steeped in piety. Nobody,
place, the boys taking part in the Plays must be God-fearing,
must absorb into their whole character something that was
fact — that the eternal Spirit must live in ever new
convinced that all cultural life, all spiritual life must be

Title: Memory and Love
Matching lines:

together. So you must be clear that when I tell you of experiences
view, for naturally it must be unconscious — no, when the soul
without pain, what has to be experienced in this way. For then he must
as in song and in declamatory speech there must be united what a man is,
the task of puzzling out intuitively how the Kabiri must have appeared

Title: Lecture: The Experiences of Sleep and their Spiritual Background
Matching lines:

ordinary means of knowledge, must, on the other hand, endeavour to find
Inspired and Intuitive Knowledge, I must portray it as if it were
of sleep, anxiety. Into this anxiety must flow power man has gained from
we must insist upon a strict science for the world of the senses, and
system. If we must say for the day-time: the white corpuscles, the red
us to breathe in and breathe out — then we must say for the
in reality a cosmic experience and because he must pass through this
comprehensive sense, we must recognise that human consciousness too is
which he is not yet conscious. He must receive it into his

Title: Lecture: About Horses That Can Count and Calculate
Matching lines:

gestures, so that we must say: These almost imperceptible gestures
which I have reached. Nevertheless I must point out that what I shall
now tell you must be described absolutely as a hypothesis, just because
must allow itself to be connected with the whole apparatus of the earth.
It must in fact be considered

Title: Threefold Order II: Lecture 1: Influence of the human will upon the course of economic life
Matching lines:

undertaking, must each time pay good heed to the
that spiritual science must come in and rectify errors; and
facts, such as these, one must look, that is, to
however, one must observe life itself. And one will then
support a thing with figures, then his conclusions must be
must die too! Statistics are meant for something quite
souls; — though then, indeed, one must go on to examine
barbarism, then one must actively will the thing
strictly speaking, something that must not rise
above a certain level, and mustn't sink
connection in which one must consider them; for, what goes to
consequently; and this consequential thinking must be carried
unnecessary work. And that is the point. One must learn to
another, it should be obvious that one must not directly
it must be said, that the Anthroposophical Press at any rate
other crises; and yet again it must be examined — not
clearly aware, that statements such as I made to-day must be
atmosphere was created,” one must look exactly at what this
what the money stands for, — one must point out
— or must be supplemented by something else which will
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Threefold Order II: Lecture 2: On Propaganda of the Threefold Social Order
Matching lines:

till now. In discussing a subject of this kind, I must really
— spiritual, political, economical, — one must
ones to be settled; but that these also must be settled on
economic life. In other words: a definite article must be
economic combinations; and this must be the standard
finds no difficulty. I must confess that, so far, I have met
Germany during the war; It must be left to the people above,
at headquarters; they must know all about it! — And so,
Question. [ Note 1 ] You must not
Social Question is, that it must be compared with a real
is the first thing we have to achieve. We must decide to
not so easy to settle public affairs. I must say that for me
must be based, not in substance, but as regards the way of
You must
people! There must be a clean sweep of everything to do with
these horrible old parties; something quite new must come to
many of you must be asking himself, why there should be this
power of the spirit, after all, which must create social
facts. But then, this inner power of the spirit must
must be set in its place; — that there is no other
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Reincarnation and Immortality: Lecture I: Free Will, Immortality
Matching lines:

There must be some reason why humanity finds it so difficult to
scientifically. It also tells itself that there must be
scientist of spirit first must give an idea as to how he
And this is what I must deal with first — the path that
development. We ourselves must take the soul in hand, and
knowledge in the natural sphere. We must, of course, be quite
which was not even noticeable. Precisely the opposite must be
for spiritual investigation. Nothing must enter our soul unless
There is a further point I would like to mention. Not only must
false mysticism, it must also be removed from everything that
with our full consciousness, must be our example and pattern.
must be emphasized that whoever believes it is possible to
spirit must emphasize that consciousness must be present
are quite different from those we must use when ordinary
real mysteries of his nature, we must apply the idea of
only in sleep. All the time we are awake the head must suffer
intuition — this is the kind of truth that must be seen

Title: Reincarnation and Immortality: Lecture II: The Historical Evolution of Humanity
Matching lines:

over the whole earth demand judgment from us. We must know what
must say that I find Woodrow Wilson as a thinker and scientist
that could hardly be bettered. I must say that some of the
is shocking that one must say such things, but the present time
must learn to grasp things as they really are. Taking care to
consciousness. And here I must come back to something that I
pictures, in imaginations, must be called forth from the depths
of historical evolution. These imaginations must then
by many geologists is called the flood. We must think of this
public a finding of the science of spirit. One must approach
must now be achieved again by humanity, only consciously. We
origin. This is important, and I must single it out as a
dreamed as history. This is something that humanity must grasp,
must know what is stirring in humanity from east to west, what
is coming out in the events of today. We must be equal to this
reality that is hammering so dreadfully upon our doors. We must
History must generate enthusiasm for the true, real and

Title: Necessity for Spiritual Knowledge: Lecture 1
Matching lines:

into making a compromise, this must be done consciously and
not lightly dismissed with a few words. It must be quietly
must not make a compromise with what we know; we must not
spiritual world must be treated with seriousness. The
culture, must, however, take stand on the same ground as
natural science. It must deal in all seriousness with what I
present time. These things today must have our earnest
why this is so, the answer must be: As we as men have entered
a quite different attitude to the spirit. Naturally this must
Waldorf School) But just because these things must be said
wisely on the one hand, on the other hand they must be
of it. Today attention must be focused on the soul. Today
account must be taken not merely of what comes from physical
within him as fruits of past earthly lives. We must approach
wanting to find the Christ must do so by direct perception.
Things must be
actively to penetrate what today must prevail as spiritual in
do individually, for example in teaching, must be done out of
Feeling must be
so that something else must arise, and so forth. But if one
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Necessity for Spiritual Knowledge: Lecture 1 (alternate translation)
Matching lines:

men must not have a feeling merely for theories about the
to be active in the Spirit must work outwards from
really seriously; and to-day these things simply must be
taken seriously. To-day men must not want to come to
to make some compromise, we must be fully aware of it. We
must never imagine that what we are doing perhaps under the
basis for knowledge which is trustworthy. To-day things must
knowledge of the spiritual world simply must be taken
which has really arisen out of modern culture must, however,
of the Renaissance” must be taken seriously. And if we
external reality itself (unhindered as he must be by any
spiritual — he cannot understand that which must work
world. These are the things which must be deeply thought
Humanity of the present must begin to realise that these
connection, and man must now, out of his own free-will, waken
the spirit, now, and in future, he must develop towards the
spirit out of his own free knowledge. He must, in a certain
in man. Hence it must become possible for us to confront the
which must naturally be put before humanity it general in a
just because on the one side there must be discretion and
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Necessity for Spiritual Knowledge: Lecture 2
Matching lines:

world. Now, for every really thinking man, the question must
must arise as to whether the time is ripe for this
onwards, there must be an expansion to a universal or cosmic
cosmic consciousness, which must take the place of a
present time, but it must be extended; what is to be found in
that book must be deepened and widened.
outline the nature of the consciousness which must be
of man must necessarily realise what terrible harm is
problem which must be understood in the light of the very
cannot be changed. The aim of mankind must be directed at the
which must be reckoned with when it is a question of
in old age, one must have learnt in childhood how to fold the
sense; but it must do so again to a greater degree. Men must
that children now must be just the same as they were when
born now must be just the same as I was in the year 1860! Now
respectable age had when we were children. We must realise
State is necessary for modern times and that it must be put
existence is obtained for humanity it must remain for all
and for particular times; there must be concrete thinking
indicate to you how things must be looked at with reference
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: The Ten Commandments
Matching lines:

members of human nature, so you must imagine the Being who
this way we must translate the announcement of the
the “I” does, the archetypal-”I” must
found rest, so mankind must separate workdays and festive days,
so also must that, which you posses after your “I”
in the flesh, an incarnated God, they must first learn to grasp
that a gradual, healthy development must ensue, in order for

Title: At the Gates: Lecture I: The Being of Man
Matching lines:

these earlier methods we must include religions, and this wisdom was a
be very useful for curiosity-addicts; but Theosophy must be carried
must go deeper. Even superficial observation will make it clear that
possible. He must therefore possess something which enables him to use
from that of ordinary sleep. There must be a close rapport between
dimmed and dulled. To grasp theosophical truths a man must be quite as
the nature of the etheric body by direct vision must be able to maintain
soul for this same soul. It must sound forth from the soul and the soul
must give itself its own name; no other soul can utter it. Hence the
superior to the animals. We must realise the tremendous significance
the physical body itself, a man must learn to control the breath and

Title: At the Gates: Lecture II: The Three Worlds
Matching lines:

to life. As its fruits it brings us two things we must have if we are
firm foundation for morality, we must supply the soul with fuel in the
he is merely preached at and told he must be nice and truthful.
past history of humanity — but he must first learn how to do it.
image of Caesar must not be compared with Caesar's individuality, which

Title: At the Gates: Lecture III: Life of the Soul in Kamaloka
Matching lines:

from it. If we want to understand sleep properly, we must recall the
condition we must realise that in his earthly life a man's consciousness
moments in Kamaloka which must be singled out as specially important and

Title: At the Gates: Lecture IV: Devachan
Matching lines:

We must remember, however,

Title: At the Gates: Lecture V: Human Tasks in the Higher Worlds
Matching lines:

But you must not think
for instance, must things have been in northern Siberia when the mammoth,
How different things must have been here, when primeval forest still
We must not imagine that

Title: At the Gates: Lecture VI: The Upbringing of Children. Karma.
Matching lines:

the first seven years. Hence during these years we must try to influence
then, we must direct our efforts to the etheric body, the vehicle of
desires. Accordingly, when the etheric body is set free we must take
every care to develop these features; we must influence a child's
faculties so early. Our age sins greatly in this respect. Care must
and analogies; we must store his memory with them and must see to it
sense-world. We must bring before him examples taken from the lives
of the great men of history, but there must be no talk of “this
impressions. How grateful Goethe must have been to his mother for telling
specially important for the child of this age is authority. It must
not be an enforced authority — the teacher must gain his authority
demands that the type of people chosen to be teachers must be those whose
an answer to them. If we are to face life with strength and hope we must
it is just this that must depress a man and rob him of all hope. But
do must produce its effect, and whatever I accomplish now, by way of
he must look after changing his karma by his own efforts.”
ascribes everything to self-redemption. You say a man must work out
entirely on self-help and self-development; he must recognise that he can
reincarnation. This does not mean that each one must bear the consequence
of his own actions, but that the consequences must be borne by someone,

Title: At the Gates: Lecture VII: Workings of the Law of Karma in Human Life
Matching lines:

his physical body. For the moment we must consider how all this extends
he must try-to prepare these as much as possible in his astral body.
etheric body. If he wants to be born with a good memory, he must exercise
his memory as much as he can; he must practise looking back over the
understand health and illness, we must bear in mind how complicated the
The fact is that we must

Title: At the Gates: Lecture VIII: Good and Evil. Individual Karmic Questions.
Matching lines:

is good or bad you must first eat one yourself. In other words, the
of logical thought. From this we must conclude that accurate thinking
evil race. You will find this stated in the Apocalypse, but it must
not be misunderstood. We must distinguish between the development of
if good is to rise to the heights of holiness, it must first overcome
gradually to find a place for itself, there must be warm blood in the
be seen that the physical organs must be in proper condition if the higher
persons concerned must be born again as contemporaries. How does this

Title: At the Gates: Lecture IX: Evolution of the Earth
Matching lines:

developed since the earliest times up to the present day, we must first
how these bodies have evolved, we must realise that it is not only man
But we must not picture
But we must not imagine seven successive Globes; it is always the same

Title: At the Gates: Lecture X: Progress of Mankind Up To Atlantean Times
Matching lines:

forms. You must picture the spirit descending from above and enfolding each
all-pervading air. Of course the event I have been describing must not be

Title: At the Gates: Lecture XI: The Post-Atlantean Culture-Epochs
Matching lines:

will of your God. Your's must be a bad God if he does not teach his
it was written: Behind nature there must be God. And he came to realise
that he must seek for God with his spirit. That is in fact the meaning
outer world. I must sink into my inner being and seek for Him in my
heart; I must follow after Him towards a higher spiritual condition.”
reality was an image of the Divine, which must not be turned away from
senses; if one faculty develops, another must fade away. The gift of

Title: At the Gates: Lecture XII: Occult Develpment
Matching lines:

anyone who aspires to occult development must among other things get
rid of the following form of egoism. He must not say: “What good
them for myself? That implies a lack of trust. He must trust a person
You must picture it in this way: when you wake up and remember all
as a foundation for wisdom; the pupil must wait for them to enter into
But he must always realise that everything there is symbolical.
does not want to injure himself, morally as well as physically, he must
He must remind himself
in the following exercises, which must be practised in addition to
tranquillity into the course of thinking. You must take a definite idea,
action. You must compel yourself to some action, however trivial,
on. You must therefore give up a little time to performing actions which
from its ordinary meaning. During occult development you must never
certain circumstances you must exclude all that you have experienced
The occultist must do this quite consciously. For instance, if someone
The occultist must always leave a way open to believe. He must go so
he bars the way to new experiences. You must always be open to new
This is a natural outcome of the other five qualities. The pupil must
must first pass through the stage of spiritual sight and only then comes
to his Guru, who must even advise him on every action he may take. This

Title: At the Gates: Lecture XIII: Oriental and Christian Training
Matching lines:

must strive to have no needs, no desire for anything in the world, and
to do only what the outer world demands of him. He must even suppress
any feeling of pleasure at doing good to someone; he must be moved to
if he has to spend money, he must not think of his own wishes or desires
but must say to himself: “I need this to maintain my body or to
culture must embody a certain pattern which will give expression to
its inner character. Modern civilisation must recover the forms it has
lost; it must learn again how to give external expression to its inner
must begin to do what others will achieve at some time in the future,
he must learn not to kill with his breath. That is Pranayama,
development has to anticipate this process as far as possible He must
deprive his breath of the capacity to kill, and must organise his breathing
your breath and breathing out again — this must be done rhythmically,
to work on him. The occult teacher says to the pupil: “You must
the pupil has done that for a while he must learn to make himself deaf
and blind to all sense-impressions; he must turn away from them and
occult training must study intensively. They are symbolic concepts which
the pentagram, symbols which occultism can explain. The pupil must keep
thought. On these, too, the pupil must focus his attention. Finally,
“Before the eye can see, it must be incapable of tears.”
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: At the Gates: Lecture XIV: Rosicrucian Training - The Interior of the Earth - Earthquakes and Volcanoes
Matching lines:

You must not imagine that
of our own soul-life. But we must make it quite clear to ourselves that
whenever you have five minutes for it. You must start from the principle
that all characteristics are one-sided; you must learn to recognise
effective. If you are industrious, you must ask yourself whether your
must be acquired alongside it.
not to let anyone finish what he is saying, you must keep a watch on
as far as possible, when someone else is talking. Then you must accustom
this right”. Above all you must get rid of the notion that your
you must cultivate patience, in the occult sense of the word. Most people
to be divine but is not so at all. We must come out of ourselves if we are
study, a modern European cannot get to know himself. He must try, first
He must learn to think in harmony with the world-order. He must say
to himself: “If others have thought this, it must be a possible
not swear to it as a dogma, but by studying it he must get to know what
it is. The pupil must learn about the evolution of sun and planets,
is it and how do we achieve it? As we go through the world we must observe
into the life of the soul. Everything must become for us a symbol in
life; it must be overcome. This form of training is particularly well
all epochs says the following about the interior of the Earth. We must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: First Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

must also realize, I was only told that this lecture-course was
can be derived from Goethe's general world-outlook. We must begin by
things we really must reach clarity. You see, dear Friends, along the
and calculating. Arithmetic — we must be clear on this —
had to read it in a cube of rock-salt. Yet in the latter we must find
phenomena of Nature and must indeed hold good among them.
got to b; thus I can calculate how strongly I must pull
real pull, a real force is exercised. Here I must somehow measure the
force; I must approach Nature herself; I must go on from thought to
Parallelogram of Movements. It must be measured and ascertained
forces must be derived empirically, by dint of outer experience.
our own thinking; mechanical phenomena on the other hand must first
involves realities of the outer world. What, in effect, must be
parallelogram of forces on the other hand there must be a mass
must not forget. There must be a mass at the point a, to begin with.
you put this question, you must ask again: How will you recognize it?
gramme — into movement, there must be some force proceeding
this kind of force involves, we must have recourse to the balance
undoubtedly determine apart from external Nature. But we must also be
actual phenomena in their surroundings. Yet we must recognize that in
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Second Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

hand it is no less significant that we must have recourse to quite
approach Nature we must consider how the point comes to be moving.
move, it must be something in outer space. In short, we must suppose
which the force is acting on the point. Finally we must take account
of the fact that the point must be something in space, and this
gets bigger. This too we must take into account; we have an ever
equation: the bigger the mass, the bigger the force must be. What
whatever goes beyond the phoronomical domain must always be beyond
m on the other hand, I must first ask: Is there anything in
you can indeed, but your first step must be to make yourself more
something with your finger. Now we must ask ourselves: Is there
we must admit: Our
is in Nature, you must bring in the states of consciousness. Without
has grown, — how much must be subtracted to restore the
life of soul — we must not reckon merely with the ponderable
spiritual must now be conceived in so strong and robust a way as to
Physical science must
the connection and you know at once: so it must be, — the
the environment. On the contrary, we must aver (and once again, we
organization of the eye. To describe it we must say: our astral body
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Third Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

I really must ask you to swallow the bitter pill (I mean, those of
yourselves: Here we get stuck! You must attribute it to the unnatural
really healthy ideas into a modern school. We must find ways of
Following what has actually happened with my drawing, I must say: the
the phenomena in this case I must say: the cylinder of light has been
evident: the broadening must somehow be connected with the shorter
stronger resistance, to which must give way. From the surface of the
water onward I must give way to the stronger resistance, and, that I
resistance of the water is harder for me to overcome. Hence I must
again. We must be clear that we ourselves are being active. We,
begin with the activity of the eye from the very outset. We must be
surrounding and more peripheral cells. I must conceive the forming of
must ask: Why do the seven colours appear to us in grey, all of one
colours are thus put together again, which must once more give

Title: Fourth Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

what you actually see will emerge in all detail. Only you must hold
indeed most interesting, and we must try to get a clear idea of what
step. Here then we must obtain an alternation of light and dark,
lighter it must grow there, — or else one would have to assume
will not do. In light, the particles of ether must be moving at right
You must realize what
be the eventual explanation; they must contain their own explanation.
reflected. It is to the light itself that we must look, if we desire

Title: Fifth Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

must be at least equal to the strength of light that is just being
however we must get hold of the pure facts.
the phenomena, in a manner of speaking, side by side. What we must
“Konigsberg” habit must be got rid of, or else it might
knowledge you have no alternative, but must say to yourselves: The
You must refer it to an astral relation to the light. But you may

Title: Sixth Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

off the experimental part until tomorrow. We must determine still
find your way back to the pure facts. You must first cultivate the
find the direction in which the light will be refracted, you must
part, we must admit the lighter part is displaced simply as the upper
must take the dark seriously, — take it as something real. (The
filled with darkness of a certain intensity. We must proceed from the
must approach these things with the help of some comparison. Truly,
withdraw, to suck at us and take away. So too must we distinguish
namely the polarity of warm and cold. Yet we must needs perceive an
underlying reason why they do so; there must be some inner reason.
phenomenon, we must examine to what extent it is a reality in itself,
we may say: here something similar must be at work. Some kind of
vibration must be beating on the eye. But we soon see it cannot be
ether and try to calculate what they suppose must be going on in this
could compute what these vibrating little cobolds must be up to in
assumption that there must be some kinship between the phenomena of
one was forced to admit that the two realms must have to do with each

Title: Seventh Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

insight into Science, and you must look on all that I bring forward
will produce the phenomenon and you must now look through on to the
Theory of Colour it must of course be rectified.
one thing we must insist on in this connection. The
warmth-condition of our surroundings? We must admit, we have a very
must distinguish between different levels in our consciousness. One
this; so too must we partake in the element of air. We must

Title: Eighth Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

is s, the whole wave-movement must be advancing n
earlier lecture. I said that we must carefully distinguish all that
real in the world outside myself, — then I must concentrate
least candid and straightforward, only he must not then go on to
is another pendulum clock; it must, admittedly, be of a certain
self-contained when outwardly regarded, but we must not therefore
itself, it is in truth an abstraction. I must go on to the totality
through the ear must first interact in a certain way with the inner
muscular in character must be related to the larynx. This of course
looking for metamorphoses in crude, external ways. You must be able
or oscillations. We must make greater demands on the qualitative

Title: Ninth Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

scientific knowledge. Now to prepare for tomorrow, I must today
is, the 19th century was chiefly filled with the idea that we must
first fifteen years, say, of our century; you must admit that a
Suppose you have a magnet or electromagnet. (I must again presume
scientists, the rays must here be undergoing further modification.
must suppose, have hitherto the right not to regard as sheer
of sleep. We must be fully clear that this is so. Consider then
must descend whenever we come up against the simple element of
electricity is based on matter. Now on the contrary we must assume,
atoms; now we must think of the electrons, moving through

Title: Tenth Lecture (First Scientific Lecture-Course)
Matching lines:

ether. This “ether” however, as you must see, proved a
space of our own conceiving? We must admit: the space which we
thinking must in themselves become more saturated with reality. It
penetrate into reality; you must begin again from another
We must
indeed; and to do this, my dear Friends, we must become aware of
more than the material waves. I must now perceive physically, what
and magnetism on the other. Increasingly therefore, this must
electricity and magnetism, so also must we understand the structure
is most essential to give the realities a chance to unfold. We must
Spirit. This is the feeling we must have. So much is crumbling, of
developments must come in place of what is breaking down. This
and Laplace. And you must realize how much is yet to do for the
on in the proper way, a far closer link must in future be forged
Universities. Questions of mobilization in future must include all
the link was not yet close enough — the link which we must
dear Friends, must learn anew, and that in many fields. Once human

Title: Man/Being/Spirit/Soul: Lecture I: Man as a Being of Spirit and Soul
Matching lines:

the example and ideal of natural science, must take its place
special must arise within human soul life, where
present-day humanity, it must nevertheless be said that this
it must be said that those who find that this is in fact so,
This is the way spiritual observation works. We must be quite
justified. The science of spirit must penetrate from the soul

Title: Man/Being/Spirit/Soul: Lecture II: The Psychological Expression of the Unconscious
Matching lines:

of spirit which can and must be placed alongside ordinary
But I must take certain things for granted, which were
which demand quick decisions, where the situation must be
kinds of descriptions that the scientist of spirit must give.
which must have started at that moment. But now what goes
These are two important characteristics that we must hold
have, must be regarded from the viewpoint of the science of
important thing. This is what must be realized.
In such matters we must be sure of distinguishing where
that must be observed. Because the science of spirit keeps its
further, for I must turn to another aspect which can be
presentiment which must have appeared before him when he

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture I
Matching lines:

measuring heat. It must be assumed that you are acquainted with them.
time when people must pay attention to certain other things if they
science itself must come certain questions simply overlooked in
be designed to show why today such questions must be asked. From the
itself, a relation which must be all means be established in certain
being. Certain questions must be asked, questions that call above
It is such questions as these that must be raised today if we are to
manner strikingly opposed to outer reality. I must call your attention
whole thing is absurd. But if we reason that Achilles must cover the
truths which turn out not to be true. For we must conclude if Achilles
must, therefore, consider what Achilles really does, and not simply
thinking “Achilles must pass over every point covered by the
But what we must do is to go to a condition of emptiness and then go
to be observed in the sun must be considered as attractive forces not
as pressures of the like. The sun's corona, for instance, must not be
thought of as it is considered by the modern physicist. It must be
What must be understood is this: when we go from ordinary reckoning
must be made clear that in certain instances one can set up
must be defined to what extent our concepts and calculations are only

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture II
Matching lines:

length contributed by the expansion. This must be added on. Since I
by heat, I must multiply the original length by a factor consisting of
I must write down:
imagine thickness added to the surface, this thickness must be treated
Now I must always remember that we are here in the Waldorf School and
everything must be presented in its relation to pedagogy. Therefore I
The history of the development of physics must be called in to a
one of extraordinary importance must be added.
physical concept that we can depend on in this case must be strictly
according to the principles laid down in the last course. We must
must not forget the manifested facts and must experiment with the
facts in mind, that is, we must remain in the field where the
fluid.) Such factual matters should be kept in mind and we must remain
basis of our available concepts. We must first, if we are to be able
questions. We must first ask: Whence comes the possibility for
could not have all these phenomena taking place through heat. You must
water we must translate it by our word fluid; the word
of the earth, that liquid and gaseous bodies must do likewise. You
cosmic regions beyond the earth. It is in this way we must understand
ten year period between 1657 and 1667. You must picture to yourselves

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture III
Matching lines:

increase in temperature. It must not be concluded from this however,
subsequently.) Heat must be added in order to bring about melting, but
quicksilver is a liquid, we must keep clear in our minds that it is
to reach point e or f. You must go outside to reach these points.
at a distance in front of the board. In this case you must leave the
Therefore, you must realize that you have to conceive of
as different entirely in its nature from space quantities. You must
you must think of as of the third power, the cubed
must go beyond three dimensional space for the last member of the
You see, I am showing you how we must, as it were, break a path if we
fluid must be poured into a vessel,
direction. In order to hold it, I must put it into a vessel closed on
opposites. The solid body provides for itself that which I must add to
gas but contracting the walls all around, you must use pressure. You
following way: That which I must add to the gas from the outside is

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

always surrounded. I must remind you that this outer air surrounding
increase the pressure on the gas its volume decreases. We must extend
greater the volume the smaller must be the pressure acting on the gas.
these must be placed side by side if we are to approach the nature of
basis for pedagogy we must consider the matter from two aspects. On
the one hand, we must build up a knowledge of the method of thinking
of modern physics and on the other, we must become acquainted with
what must happen if we are to throw aside certain obstacles that
That is, we must add a second dimension to the first. The standard of
to their students as to show that one must leave ordinary space in
studied know that the human being must rise through the physics of
only mechanical facts in space. Life must be a mechanical thing, soul
phenomena must be mechanical and spiritual things must be
realm of heat. We must therefore ask the questions: what does it
I am to comprehend the whole reality I must insert into my judgment of
the fact that I must leave three dimensional space in order to relate
relation to heat and to pressure. Such a fact must be considered as a
But there is something else that must be taken into account as a
and color, would be immediately perceived. We cannot do this. We must
must be intimately bound up with us as human beings, because after

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture V
Matching lines:

possible to do so, however, and I must accordingly arrange my lecture
We then noted particularly, and this must be emphasized, that our
must deceive ourselves here. Man is thinking of tone when he speaks of
the gap must be bridged if physics is to advance. To this end we must
begin to grasp how we must orient ourselves, in observing phenomena so
only able to think abstractly. For the attempt must be made to get
in the physics books. There we must think in such a way that we use
imagination, then the abstract ideas must be completely altered,
thinking takes me. But in that case I must remain within what can be
very definite reason. You must make the following clear to yourselves:
the concept of mass, this is not so. The matter must then be put
and time or ourselves and space. That is, we must grow inwardly into
experiences in this region, since a person must so transform himself
We must now set up on the one side, all the things we have just tried
water, we must extend them to include the water of the whole earth and
not terrestrial. In other words, we must not merely look on the earth
for the activities of a gas, we must bring in the environment of the
earth to help us out, we must go out into space and seek there the
melting or boiling point, then there enter in things that must now

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

must wait until the water vapor returns to the same temperature as it
it solidified. You know that water changed to ice at 0°C. and it must
temperature under its melting point, but the pressure must be
produce crystal form which must be present and active to a certain
You must include the liquid surface in your
must be confined all around except on the liquid surface. It
must indicate the movement of the water particles when it actually
that it is an unknown entity to us at the outset. But we must do this
condition where it is more evident. We must see whether in the fluid

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture VII
Matching lines:

must seek as well as we can to force our way into the realm of the
factors and their resummation.” Having said this, he must
show plainly, very plainly, that what he says is true, so we must show
Naturally however, we must penetrate to real physical thinking before
place. Solids have a form of themselves. Liquids must be enclosed in a
the formation of the liquid surface, then we must do it in the
following way. We must, if we are to stick to the observable, in some
must conceive of that which is active in the liquid surface, and which
to limit the space occupied by it, we must do so by placing it in a
toward the planet would see them always flying off. We must think in
formerly represented gravity. And we realize from this that we must
earth gives it a liquid surface and I must put this liquid into a
tetrahedron is put through this transformation, you must imagine to
within it is gaseous. With this outside space filled you must imagine
in a tetrahedral hole. There it is empty. You must then make the
rightly on the gas we must look upon it as a form, but as a negative
night. In the future we must be able to make a given experiment during
cosmos. You can realize that the research institute that must in the
views of the world will have weighty problems. They must reckon with
attention must be turned to especially. And on such a path will we
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture VIII
Matching lines:

Today we will do just the opposite. We showed yesterday that we must
changed into work must appear as such in the water. In case of a
then this must be considered as transformation of the energy already
forms of energy must be transformations of each other. No form of
which heat is transformed into work. We see that heat must be present
Now we must make clear to ourselves the following point. Is there ever
must take into account that I have not stuck the needle into my
clothes, but into my organism. This organism must be considered as a
What must be taken into account especially is: That it is never
system. I must keep in mind that this whole experimental procedure
added to the system, but must have come into it from the outside. If
corresponds to form in the solid, we must look for it in condensation
so the gas pictures the realm which we must conceive as lying next to
must look in this X region for something corresponding to but beyond
considerations.) I must look for something else there in the X region,
material. And this extension we have spoken of must, if we are to be

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture IX
Matching lines:

I must ask you to note especially how both these experiments show that
must emphasize again and again a beautiful utterance of Goethe's
with his environment. He must take in more oxygen from the air in the
necessary for the advance of physics, stating that nothing must enter
What must take place if there is to be such a reality as the U realm?
In this realm there must be pictured that which in solids is a
realm must give us a picture of the solids. In the world of solids we
must find something that happens in a similar manner to the
in accordance with reality. And this must parallel the picturing of
the fluid world by solids. In other words: in the U world we must be
able to see an action which foreshadows the solid world. We must in
some way be able to see this activity. We must see how, under the
must come into existence as a reality what further manifests as
figures, one must seek for their origin in an entirely different
to the organ of hearing. We must not feel it necessary to identify
what we are conscious of as tone. We must seek for something in the
these are present in a suitable fashion. What really happens we must
of color. If we are to comprehend the total phenomenon we must make it
integral portion of the “All” and must be comprehended as a
realms. Now when we go further, we must really come back from the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture X
Matching lines:

This is one thing we must keep in mind simply as a phenomenon. There
itself. If we wish to speak accurately we must ask what is spreading,
piece, we must ask the question: is it not perhaps a very confused
You see, I must emphasize to you that we have to make for ourselves
brings us to an enormously important consideration. What must we place
man. And now we must ask ourselves, are these forces to be found in
man. When the human being first enters physical existence, he must be
related very plastically to his formative forces. That is, he must do
or philosophizing, but must be got from reality. And in reality we see
order to function in our will nature. Indeed heat must appear if
along a line into the indeterminate. The opposite must be the case
here. And how can we state this? How must it be within man? We must
going off into infinity, so that we can no longer follow it, we must
from the states of aggregation we must think of as going out of space.
That is, the forces that are in heat must so manifest themselves in
shows us that when we think of her in relation to man, we must leave
Then what works into the nature of man must be set down as negative.
nature of heat, insofar as this belongs to the outer world, must be
add: “if I think about its form the matter must be negative, in a
the negative of pressure, or suction, must come into the picture.
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture XI
Matching lines:

twelve color series which must be possible? Imagine to yourselves that
primary thing, has working within it certain forces. Not only must
This idea we must link up with another, which comes to us when we go
picture of the realm immediately above it, then you must look in the
non-solid realm. I must make it clear to myself, if I wish to keep my
must now say “heat is motion,” but in an entirely different
must conceive of as suction forces while material things obviously
they become suction forces. Attention must be paid to the fact that in
theoretically today in this presentation in an auditorium. It must not
instance, the usual concepts of energy must be thrown out. This
where doubts are expressed which must arise from a straightforward
red portion must be thought of as non-spatial. Using this intermediate
What I am outlining to you here, my dear friends, you must think of as
We must seek the deeds of heat as Goethe sought out the
deeds of light. Then we must see how knowledge of the being of

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture XII
Matching lines:

call your attention to a certain fact. This fact is one which we must
but an image and it is this we must hold firmly in mind. As a matter
the U region, and you can see that the light realm must have a
relation to heat and so also must the realm of chemical activity. On
heat or in gases must have a relation to the essence of tone. For tone
We have the U region and this U region must have a relation to the
solids on the surface of the earth. We must first ask the question and
non-transparent metals? This question must be considered and the
and I must multiply by this factor.
the time. Obviously then, I must multiply through by a constant
is this we must keep our attention on.
irregularity in the partition of heat is present I must bring it into
my considerations in some way. I must bring in the differences that
movement of heat. If this is considered for an instant of time, I must
mention it, since we must keep it in mind. I refer to the relation
must not think of light, heat and chemical effects as stretched out in
we must really represent a heat quantity working within a body by
means of our formula. How must we represent qualitatively the relation
the opposite way to reach the chemical effects. This fact must be kept
wish to bring heat and chemical effects into relation, we must, if we
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture XIII
Matching lines:

but they must be followed out in detail.
least, that a relation must exist here similar to the ones I have in
phenomena to light, one must say that we are not dealing with a
really mean something to you, you must work them over within
it the appearance it has, all this you must consider as soul and
matter, as originally united. That is to say, you must conceive of
still different type will be valid. Our modern physics must conform
absurdities, physics must be freed of the tendency to study
energy must change into heat and the earth come to a heat death. This
process must be symbolized as a circle. It is only thus that we

Title: Warmth Course: Lecture XIV
Matching lines:

fluid element must enter in its own particular way into the solid or
must keep before our eyes an interpenetration, and with this
must not think of that which comes to clear manifestation and is
with this effect as it interpenetrates physical bodies. We must
activities? Then it must happen, considering the matter simply from
sets in. When we put the fluid element before us in thought, we must
leads us to the point when we have to say: There must be some reason
air outside of us. This must be looked upon as nonsense.
from without we must put the matter in this way: beneath the sphere of
element of the earth. How must we then conceive of these various
shaped from within as the solid bodies are. How must we picture this
to ourselves? Well, we must conceive of it as the opposite condition.
must think of space filled with negative matter. Within we have filled
space (see figure). We must become accustomed to thinking of an
“matterless” spaces must work in from various directions. If
designated as the planets, to which we must add also the sun.
condition of space to the opposite condition. We must learn to pass
acts on our earth we must think of as localized in the planets around
This indeed, is what we have to do; we must know that when we
the condition where there is negative matter. There must be a region
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture I
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
“pale” this must not be twisted into the assertion that
must not be so feeble that they stick up there in the head. They must
centuries. But these thoughts must get a heart as well!
civilized world. It is simply so, and we must be conscious of it.
out of which Goethe grew, and we must find it again. And if it is
his soul. Human beings must again be capable of feeling, not weakly,
false. They must be capable of feeling things not weakly but
light must come that will flood this unclear seeking without making
it dry or cold. We must find this light, while preserving the heart's
the shutters which the older generation had closed so tightly must be

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture II
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
their institutes and libraries must be there. But the human being
years of youth. We must come together with human beings with whom we
must grow old in earthly life — however young we may still be.
something must be got out of the human being himself.
the remotest notion of what must be done now, when human beings who
still have a soul in their bodies must inevitably face the
School education must be listened to with other ears than those with
give a picture of what Waldorf Education is, we must say that it
needed today. First of all, the teachers must be awakened, and then
the teachers must awaken the children and the young people.
What must be sought for is a new experience of Christ. We are
longer. Out of the darkness in the human soul, a light must be found
once again. The spiritual world must be experienced in a new way.
time in the historical evolution of mankind there must be an
life, must mean something to one another. It is this that has from
human again: human beings must be awakened.
Golgotha must become a living experience again. In the Mystery of
communities people are seeking for today. The Spirit must be the
The awakening must be sought within the human being himself, in the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture III
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
for the next few days, and I must appeal to you to try to arouse a
today. But we must realize that people saw something in phosphorus,
sleep: “I must take my fill of beer to prepare for sleep.”
this demand is in his very blood. You must be clear about this. You
must get your head so strong again that it can stand not only
logical, abstract thinking, but even living thinking. You must not
man. Man must work out of the forces with which he builds up his own
lecturing desk. It is out of sleep that man must bring the forces
consummated, but in a more subconscious way. Nowadays the union must
necessary vision. Humanity must attain this vision, for we are living
must penetrate us with its livingness. But because this is no longer
effect upon our dead cultural life. The Spirit must be the lightning
genuinely spiritual perception — must also be perceived in an
earthly guise, must be clothed in terms of materialistic thinking. So
ought to answer him: If knowledge is to be anything real, it must
knowledge must follow this course. It is not sought for in
but Father Mager condemns this. And yet it is exactly what he must
concepts must be kept away from that! In such cases we can only have
the present day to be cold, arid. It must be given life and inner
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
must give up the view that systems of philosophy which start from the
Principles of Ethics) must, from a scientific point of view at least,
moral intuitions, moral axioms, and that we must stop talking about
with overwhelming evidence that all moral intuitions must be
through life and meeting individuals we must have an open heart —
brought Nietzsche to the conviction: I must resolutely put aside the
way. What is known as human must be divested of the “empty
upon something which must be born out of the human being but was not
will always feel after a time that you must brush it aside. You will
being today honestly admits: I must grasp the living, the active
say only pleasant things; I must sometimes say things which will not
please everyone. Moreover I must say what I know to be true. So, in
characterization of what we must seek. In the deepest, innermost
being of the soul, we must seek for light; above all else we must
upon honesty and truth, then we shall progress, for humanity must
it can find the Spirit if only it so wills. In our time the soul must
ordinary everyday actions. We must come to spirituality in action, to

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture V
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
any discussion about moral intuitions must once and for all be
to assert “No, that must first be proved!” What man
talk about moral intuitions must be silenced, it was the final
which we ourselves must strenuously work for. This was no longer
activity, requires energy. There the lightning-flash of will must
will must come from each single individual. Courage was needed to
longer given in the form of the old impulses. Intuitions must be
impulses for the future must be produced out of moral phantasy, moral
given. The new intuitions must be produced in the sphere of each
being must be made the source of his own morality. This must be
Spiritual Activity — something that must inevitably be in sharp
through the forces of nature, but must be the remains of a living
it were itself something living. We must go back to what was the
earlier time. But upon sound reflection I must say to myself: “This
dead thinking must have originated in a living thinking which was
this one cannot build on it. One must appeal to an inner livingness,
being purely spiritual. But then one must work on to discover other
my dear friends, we must proceed as follows. On the one hand, we must
materialism but also phenomenalism. On the other, we must work to
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
living in an age when many new impulses must come into the evolution
older towards the younger generation must assume a different
must also consider: What will be the attitude of this young
here we must look still more deeply into the human soul than I have
They consider the world-riddle a system of questions that must be
resounding endlessly, that human beings must continue on into the
phrases, we must say: That joy and that love which fired human beings
obedience to duty; only the cold statement: “I must perform my
developed in such a way that action out of love must give mankind the
individualism must be borne on the love arising from perception of
another. Just as in our inner being we must call upon love for an
ethical future, so we must call upon confidence in relation to men's
intercourse with each other. We must meet the human being so that we
human being must develop from childhood so that there may be awakened
but which fills us with confidence — this must become the very
religious impulses. In quite another way, for we must strive to gain
— life must again be permeated by a religious quality. But
first and foremost it must be made evident in the sphere of
great demand of the future — must permeate social life.
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture VII
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
feeling must reckon with many disappointments prepared out of its own
state of tiredness. We must not only be able to get tired, we must
something that must be.
said that there must be an education which makes learning a game for
children; school must be all joy for the child. Yes, those who speak
tiredness. One must express it thus, though it sounds pedantic.
which must receive more careful consideration if we want to
must take the book and sit down to it as if we were sitting down in
difference there is must see it like this: Albertus Magnus seems to
things must be taken concretely. To speak of a super-sensible world
we must realize that in the young individuality sitting at the feet
science must be there, a new spiritual life, able once again to unite
what belongs to present and future ages must link itself with older
within us and towards which we are still striving, must become fully
conscious. But we must in many respects go back to older contents of
must above all things be evoked in the young. Out of confidence there
must be found that for which the young are thirsting. Our whole

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture VIII
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
destiny of the human soul, we must pay no heed to that which wells up
out of our childhood from the depths of the soul. We must look to the
Yes, we must admit that we receive our thoughts from the external
become dried up by the prejudice that in science one must be
scientifically, must be experienced as having no soul. Those who were
see, this question must set the mood if any phase of the youth
activity we must reconquer the divine nature of thinking.
One must keep in step with it and get one's thinking on the
must be trodden with courage, with the very blood of one's

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture IX
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
according to anthroposophical knowledge. You know that we must
appeared in an entirely new way. Problems must be regarded in a new
all we must ask many of our questions in a new way, in a form that
life of which he must know, but which cannot be exhausted by
again, one must speak about such things, and treat them in a
human being before he is eighteen must depend upon those who are
have been no such thing? To answer this question we must turn to the
of actual knowledge. We must be capable of inducing the young to
the question from the new point of view: How must things be in human
the eighteenth year the child cannot know anything, so he must be led
that the forces of knowledge must be awakened. To keep the young
those days must again be given life. But because today consciousness
with their mind souls. Today a different solution must be found.
than what is being done today. We must reckon with modern conditions
evolution of the human race. Here we must find the transition from
young. For this period we must find the solution of the most
submergence. The question is: How must adults handle children between
must look at life, not at theories, when one seeks to encompass the
truth must be filled if humanity is not to pine away. This must be
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture X
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
show how we must come to an education, steeped in artistic form. I
in order to understand these things thoroughly we must consider from
Grecian times quite other concepts must be used. Nietzsche felt this.
experience it consciously for consciously it must again be
through his own powers, man must arrive at finding the spiritual,
things must be emphasized to become intelligible. I do not wish to
that is to say, it must lead all studies to the point where there is
play of forces must begin to move freely. Not before thinking moves
cannot be read as other books are today. It must really
assume that philosophers would say: One must look into this Eurythmy
people get goose-flesh when one tells them that a certain book must
be read quite differently from other books, that it must be read in
that must be experienced? It is the awakening of the will out of the
studied physiologically or anatomically, but who must be livingly
This cannot be known through external perception but must be inwardly
experienced. To know this second man a kind of artistic activity must
relationship. The child must acquire an aesthetic relation to it.
must go right into the art of education. The cleft between age and
youth must be bridged not by hollow phrases but by education that is
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture XI
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
so today, after the change of teeth, we must simply pass over to a
school education in future must proceed by way of the artistic I
must have soul, and as scientist one cannot have soul. We can have
instruction must therefore be permeated by art, by human
that must work in the school. What grows between teacher and pupil
Our riches consist really in abstractions. And therefore we must free
of yesterday. We must purify our thinking and mould it, into will. To
this end we must make our individuality stronger and stronger, and
and must be awakened, and Art is the awakener. When this is developed
would educate. And as a human being he must come near to them. Those
who are to be educated must get something from him as a human being.
not bear it out — but you must admit the case may arise that
develop. So we must be quite clear upon this point: we cannot cram
things must for once be said most emphatically. For even when spoken
deeper forces must work up out of human nature if men are to give
must also be brought into our education; we should be able to
who does not learn it from prayer. This must not be understood
human being must be treated in such a way that he can grow. What
child must be given pictures capable of growth, pictures which become
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture XII
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
Dark Age would have run its course, how in a new age there must come
must not merely translate into our language what was formerly
so, we should be understanding only the old again. We must learn to
perceive it anew with the spiritual means of today. We must permeate
materiality renders today, yet one must mention how different the
quite new relation between man and man. Do not think that we must
in the sense of modern evolution we must increasingly experience
appearance. And so we must picture the people of recent centuries who
Jean Paul never got rid of it to the day of his death. We must have
be pulled to pieces. This may not seem important, yet we must notice
must be an abomination to every orthodox professor, nevertheless
man was seen within sheaths. Now we must learn to see him as an
medieval councilors. Today — I must confess — it would be
possibility for a relation between ego and ego. But this must be
that is what must be striven for, and the rest left to God, if I may
State, saying: Morality must be such that the State becomes
in practical everyday life we must be right within this great
into the classroom, must not have the feeling: “He is teaching
once fed. And so in Pedagogy one must overcome everything which lays
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Younger Generation: Lecture XIII
Matching lines:

and living wisdom in teachers and so must reject modern adults' dead
we must feel the full intensity of being surrounded by a thinking
man — could but say: Ultimately such activity must disappear
But the dragon must be conquered, and therefore the knowledge must
continually to kill the human being. But the dragon must be
untruth upon the earth. We must acquire the vision of Michael who
the dragon must be conquered. He does not suffer men to found
see how profoundly this problem must be grasped. But what has
Today everything must spring out of man's freedom. The dragon
overcoming of the dragon the human being must acquire the strength to
quite empty, must be overcome. The age of Michael who conquers the
dragon must now begin, for the power of the dragon has become great!
it is this above all that we must set going if we want to become true
must no longer nurture the dragon by cultivating a science with
so as to develop him. We must build the chariot, the vehicle for
education we must have a heart. We must learn — speaking
is the fundamental impulse of all educational doctrine. We must not
receive this art of education as a theory, we must not take it as
we offer our services because we must do so, if men are to experience
thesis must be written because there such things are discussed. But
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Lecture I: Occult Signs and Symbols
Matching lines:

occultist says about the pentagram, we must at first call to mind the
these currents are, as it were, his bony framework. You must not
unsuccessful if only he does so with patience. He must immerse
thinking out contrived, arbitrary meanings for these signs. One must
ingenious, but truthful! As an occultist one must give up lawless
thinking; one must not draw arbitrary conclusions and pass judgments.
Step by step, with the help of spiritual facts, correct thinking must
present on the Sun. You must not mix up the old Sun with the present
following his passions, you must say of him that he stands lower than

Title: Lecture: Lecture II: Occult Signs and Symbols
Matching lines:

first book of Moses, Genesis. e.Ed] we must deepen our
knowledge of various things. We must at first make clear to ourselves
acquired for the first time on the earth. Now we must turn our
however, has stayed on the old Saturn level. We must indeed

Title: Lecture: Lecture III: Occult Signs and Symbols
Matching lines:

must be our starting point. Later, in considering the other numbers,
reveal itself. There must also be shadow or darkness — that is,
life, but we must look for them at the right spots.
life must again appear, when through the Anthroposophical Movement it
the whole we must include a third aspect that stands behind these
pedantic thoughts about it, but we must look for the duality and

Title: Lecture: Lecture IV: Occult Signs and Symbols
Matching lines:

nevertheless so for the occultist. You must not forget the fact that
those who would find God must look for him in his works that are
the initiate must swallow this book. Here is indicated the time when
That he find life again in this death, a man must find the death of
member must unite, the man who has overcome death will identify
of the spiritual belongs to the spiritual and must not be profaned.

Title: Lecture: The Proclamations to the Magi and the Shepherds
Matching lines:

These inner forces must have reached a certain stage of development
this is no proof of a life before birth, it must be said that they do
of being the founder of such a ‘School of Wisdom.’ We must understand
the coming of such a Being must be recognised through wisdom
Golgotha. The Mystery of Golgotha as such must never be confused with
understanding of the Mystery of Golgotha has been lost, and we must be
grasped. It must be discovered anew. The Magi-wisdom has become
alone the heavens are studied. What has become inward in this way must
abstraction. Therefore what is now inward must be expanded into
perception of the outer universe; inward perception must lead to a new
What must never be forgotten is that the proclamations to the
When we think of the Christmas Mystery, our minds must turn to a
birth, to something that must be born anew in our time. For true
Christianity must verily be born anew. We need a

Title: Cosmic New Year: Lecture I: The Three Streams in the Life of Civilization. The Mysteries of Light, of Man, and of the Earth.
Matching lines:

enters the world of Initiation must not only know in it what every
themselves out, of which we must say: “They cannot go on like
this, they must undergo transformation.” But human beings today
There has come a time when it must be said publicly that if any
the real origin of this spiritual life, we must pass through certain
can assume a form of beauty, but we must confess that even that
We must unwind the tangle of our spiritual, political, and industrial
must separate them from one another.
life with most penetration in what I must call Goetheanism. Goethe,
In our age, clear thinking must spread over the whole earth.
Everything must be done to help forward the victory of clear thinking.
But we must be quite conscious of all that is against us when we make
things, we have against us man's love of ease. We must wean ourselves
sphere of truth. But we must become aware of what really exists.
of the whole organization, must in all earnestness, out of the depths
human morality? Is it not profoundly immoral? Such questions must be
We must express ourselves unreservedly about these things. If we show
It is not enough to take them as mere parlance. People must accustom

Title: Cosmic New Year: Lecture II: The Michael Path to Christ: A Christmas Lecture
Matching lines:

about a new ascent?” For it must have been very clear to you in
In these days we must often think of men, in the middle of the
way?” If this question is to be answered we must turn our
for our time. We must look into these things if in a deeper sense we
that mankind must become related to him. For now Michael is not the
must approach the Christ-impulse through Michael. In many respects
Today it is Christ Jesus whom we must strive to find through Michael,
that we must seek for feelings and ideas which have nothing to do with
cannot be found on the surface. They must be sought where the spirit
Science. The matter lies thus, that we must resolve to seek the real
We must endeavour clearly to understand, that that which today we call
it, a gift of that Lucifer. We must not hold merely, in a
Luciferic is dreadful, and we must get rid of it. The more we seek to
must value rightly and make a right use of that which, through
noticed. This must not be. Ahriman must not control the Economic life
on the Earth without his being noticed. We must thoroughly learn to
know his particular qualities. We must be able to oppose him with full
much that we must carefully note in human evolution up to the time of
Mankind must be protected by wisdom from regarding the Gospels in this
the centre between Ahriman and Lucifer. The Christ power must permeate
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Cosmic New Year: Lecture III: The Mystery of the Human Will
Matching lines:

should stream into it. We must say, absolutely without reserve: The
here called Anthroposophical Spiritual Science, civilization must sink
into the abyss. The work of the Heavenly Powers upon the earth must
is on the increase. I shall merely indicate this aspect. Today I must
Man must be pointed out to humanity in a comprehensive way. This
must be taken. Nevertheless, the further question must be asked:
science: Effects are the result of their causes. It is not so. We must
look elsewhere for the true causes, just as we must seek in our
causes lie in Mankind. Do you know where you must look if you wish to
on the Earth? You must investigate how the human Will, quite unknown
that he must look upon the centre of man if he wished to find the
must become an integral part of the Natural Science of the future, for
another moral impulse must surge through mankind if the Science of
Lucifer was incarnated in human form. We must not conceal the fact
will incarnate in a human body in the Western World. This fact must
which he prepares for what must come.
and that they must not deceive themselves through sleepy illusion
for the coming of Ahriman. You must realize that there is no better
something that must be made known at the present day. You know quite
it out. To have the right relation towards these Gospels we must know
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Cosmic New Year: Lecture IV: The Breaking-in of Spiritual Revelations Since the Last Third of the Nineteenth Century. Thoughts on New Years Eve.
Matching lines:

mirroring process), we must confess: What we see mirrored there, is
point. Now, however, we are living in an age in which the point must
again become a circle, an age in which the Ego must again receive a
so today our Ego must be filled with a new spiritual content, received
present, must now be made the beginning. In olden times, man had
clairvoyant revelations and did not understand them. Today man must
first understand, must exert to the utmost his intellectual
power, must exert to the utmost his reason. If he so exerts it through
The attempts of Spiritual Science must not be groping. Through such
I must say that I very nearly lost my power of speech, for it is
power of speech when a teacher of religion says: “True piety must
the Catholic Church. We must judge such things from a moral point of
view. We must ask whether anyone who deals with truth as this man does
Those only care for the future, who see how a new interest must seize
mankind, how new religious experience must spring up in mankind, so

Title: Cosmic New Year: Lecture V: The Dogma of Revelation and the Dogma of Experience. The Spiritual Mark of the Present Time. A New Year Contemplation.
Matching lines:

enthralled. This is why we must not break with their spiritual
what has happened, must say to himself: “There would not be
“A social order must be established among men, where everyone can
must be evolved where the individual capacities of each man can be
paths of abstraction in the Spiritual life. And for this we must first
We must be able to feel when spirit and soul are spoken of as reality.
inner connections which may not be overlooked any longer. We must face
present time. We ought to feel that we must say: “We have
of those who raised the warning cry: “We must prevent by means of
happening in our times and which, left to itself, must lead to
organization. Something new must be stamped upon human evolution.
These facts must become known, and to feel that these facts must

Title: Fundamentals of Anthroposophical Medicine: Lecture I
Matching lines:

I must ask my audience to be considerate
instance, physiology, can be no more than a stimulus that must
must be emphasized that the conceptions I am putting forward
perfection. This must always be remembered if we wish to
branch of knowledge today must never overlook all that natural
become active today, it must work with and not against natural
aspersions on the concepts of natural science. Indeed, I must
“clairvoyance,” as it is called. We must be quite
This is why I must ask you today to forgive these somewhat
investigation are there and must be reckoned with. Those who
an anthroposophical spiritual science must first concern
that what exists at a particular place in the organism must be
observation must determine the distinguishing feature of this
but the state of affairs determined by sense observation must
our conception of a liver cell must differ essentially from our
must rather assume that the relation of the brain cell to the
the needle itself. It must be brought into relation with the
take into account what we find — as naturally we must
Must we not relate this germ cell to the whole universe?
must be possible to approach the whole subject from another
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Fundamentals of Anthroposophical Medicine: Lecture II
Matching lines:

kidney system. The kidney system must then be discussed in
starting point, however, must be the sense-perceptible
The purely physical mode of thinking, therefore, must confine
has an etheric body. We must think of everything solid as being
the heart, so we must postulate the existence of a lawfulness
the solid, physical organization, we must assume the existence
physical organization of the human being. But then we must be
the subsequent processes must be studied by a different means
his head. (The conditions for the experiment must of course be
must be studied much more exactly than the processes that arise
the astral organization into the human organism. Here we must
human being, only of course they must cover the different
empirical data must be followed up in this or that direction.
that has been learned in this way about the human being must
by way of example, but it will show you the path that must be
is growing. We must rather take our start from the root, and so
year must be related to the sun forces of the previous year.
must be the subject of exact research; only the guiding

Title: Fundamentals of Anthroposophical Medicine: Lecture III
Matching lines:

of the skin, and also those within the human organization, must
this morning. These relationships, however, must be studied in
from the liver-kidney systems. We must realize that in the
we to think of the astral organization in the child? We must
metabolism in the child must be shaped so that it is brought
of the human nerve-sense system is necessary and we must be
put incorrectly, it must be posed in a different way. From the
said that we must pay attention to whether more or less fatigue
fourteenth years our ideal must be to work not primarily upon
must basically be regarded as proceeding from this functional
etheric systems of the human being. These diseases must be
that proceeds from the rhythm of the blood must first be looked
the very young child. We must see the cause of childhood
we must look for an intermediate phase between the fluid and
expresses itself in the nerve-sense system). We must see, so to
consider therapy.) We must succeed in enveloping the tumor with
we must first have ascertained its specific effect upon this or
the uterus or of the pylorus. One must study the path taken by
expression as a state of feverishness. The injection must be

Title: Fundamentals of Anthroposophical Medicine: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

fundamentally, simply metamorphoses of the functions that must
conditions. We must always take into account the fact that the
unfolding in the outer world. To begin with, we must remember
from outside in the plant world, for instance, must be worked
vitalization, the enlivening, must be an activity of the human
We must be clear
from this and turn to consider actual illness, we must say to
must admit that all food introduced into the human organism is
something that this organism must utterly transform, reverse.
beginning of a kind of poisoning. We must be clear, then, that
iron-bearing blood corpuscles must mean for the whole life of
buoyancy of the iron-bearing corpuscles, we know that iron must
not be far from the insight that balance must prevail here. If
Now I must say
each other better. You must naturally take such statements with
day, year by year, our organs must first be provided for by
out by the kidneys must be continually rounded off
symptoms. But we must be able to appraise the importance of
have already said, a process of devitalization that must be
slight. We must never over-stimulate the organism; whenever it
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Anthroposophical Approach to Medicine: Lecture I
Matching lines:

must ask my audience to be considerate with me to-day, because I have
must then be worked out empirically. Only on the basis of this
in any way. But it must be emphasised that the conceptions put
certain — albeit provisional — perfection. This must
knowledge to-day must never overlook all that science has
in sickness and health strives to express itself to-day, it must work
against the concepts of modern science. Indeed, I must emphasise at
point we must be quite clear. But what lies in our power is to work
point and hope there will be no misunderstanding. That is why I must
it must be remembered that spiritual-scientific investigation
results of modern empirical investigation are there and must be
reckoned with. Those who seriously pursue Spiritual Science must
in the organism, must also be studied in reference to its
empirical observation must determine the distinguishing feature of
3 o'clock in the afternoon, but the objective fact must be
this sense our conception of a liver-cell must differ essentially
body. We must rather assume that the relation of the brain-cell to
lying within the needle itself. It must be brought into
find — as naturally we must — but we reckon merely with
the confines of the human being himself? Must we not relate this
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Anthroposophical Approach to Medicine: Lecture II
Matching lines:

starting point, however, must be the objective and empirical
The purely physical mode of thought, therefore, must confine itself
saying: Man has an etheric body. We must think of everything solid as
in the relationship between the kidneys and the heart, so we must
solid, physical organisation, we must assume the existence of
organisation of man. But then we must realise that something of the
and that the subsequent processes must be studied from a different
conditions for the experiment must of course be carefully prepared.)
development the accessory organs must be studied much more exactly
only so shall we find the way, as we must do, towards seeing man, not
human organism. Here we must not think of the physical organisation,
being, only of course they must cover the different periods of his
nevertheless, that the empirical data must be followed up in this or
learned in this way about the human being must now be investigated in
merely by way of example, but it will show you the path that must be
grows. We must take our start from the root, and so from the dynamic
be an element belonging to the present year must be related to the
matters must be the subject of exact research; only the guiding

Title: Anthroposophical Approach to Medicine: Lecture III
Matching lines:

and also those within the organism, must be included. We
these relationships must be studied in more precise detail if they
system of kidneys. We must realise that in the first life-period, up
must think of the workings of the kidneys as being radiated back from
of nerves and senses. The metabolic processes in the child must not
of nerves and senses is necessary, and we must observe that while in
breathing cause fatigue. So when it is said: heed must be paid to the
Between the seventh and fourteenth years our ideal must be to work
head system. In effect, education must be imbued with the quality of
deformations must be regarded as proceeding from these functional
systems of man, we find diseases which must be considered in
rhythm of the blood must first be looked for in the counter-beat of
very young child. We must seek the cause of children's diseases
likewise in the living and sentient organism we must look for an
that we must observe the relationship existing between the physical
expresses itself in the system of nerves and senses). We must, so to
warmth, only we must first have ascertained its specific effect upon
— namely, a state of feverishness. The injection must be

Title: Anthroposophical Approach to Medicine: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

being, fundamentally, metamorphoses of those functions which must be
here we must always take account of the fact that the human organism
instance, must be worked upon by the digestive system before it can
must be an activity of the human being himself; indeed, the human
organism could not exist without it. Now it must be clear to us from
study the process of nourishment in man, we must admit that
blood corpuscles must mean for the whole life of feeling and
corpuscles, we know that iron in some form or other must be
balance must reign here. If there is no balance, if either the
I must add something in connection with the irregular working of the
that we may understand each other. You must take such statements with
adapts itself more and more. That, however, is secondary; we must
year by year, our organs must first be provided for by all that
that is radiated out by the kidneys must continually be rounded off,
must be able to judge of the nature of these symptoms. Suppose we are
devitalisation which must be reversed is taking place in the
must never be over-stimulated; whenever it is possible to use a
functions. We must apply something whereby this astral activity is
view intersect and we must realise that when the symptoms are severe,
activity of the astral organism is too feeble. We must stimulate the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Michaelmas III: The Michael Inspiration
Matching lines:

too, however, that the manner of speaking we must then adopt is no
in the Earth's dark bosom. During winter we must look down to the
of man in relation to this whole world nexus, we must say to
starting from the animal lower nature, the sulphurous element. We must
What he thus carries in his physical body, however, he must grasp in
soul and spirit, must become able to experience it within himself; he
must learn to experience this meteoric shag of the blood-iron into the
direction; in the face of that he must rather increase his strength.
Just as he must accompany living Nature in his own life, so must he
Nature-consciousness must be transformed into self-consciousness.
admonition: Nature consciousness must change in man into consciousness
must always pass over into art, since with abstract concepts one
against sulphur. We must learn not to let this process go on in the
subconsciousness, merely shaping the lower nature of Man; we must
the Easter and Christmas festivals and that of St. John, it must truly
of mankind. The Michael Festival must be linked with a great and
and iron determines the unconscious nature of man. It must be lifted
into consciousness. We must learn to know this process as the
expression of the inner conflict of Michael with the Dragon; we must
come about to which the Michael Festival may be linked. But it must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Michaelmas Va: The Michael Impulse and the Mystery of Golgotha (Part I)
Matching lines:

importance for the time in which we are living, we must remind
to-day feels hostile. But we must do so, if we wish to deal with the
The human race must however first give itself this possibility. One
If this is true as regards memory in ordinary life, we must look at
earth-lives. It is the innermost nature of the soul that we must
but to do so, we must first have comprehended the life of the soul.
has not been there for the whole of mankind, now can and must become a
bring it into the spiritual world, he must blot out his personality
through what was impressed into him from the body. In future he must
of them. We must receive this into our souls as a feeling, as an
civilisation, who will take his place? The place must be filled.
Everyone must say to himself: “Then some Angel must also
have been promoted, and must enter the ranks of the Archangels. Who is
still more important considerations which must occupy us in the next

Title: Lecture: Michaelmas Vb: The Michael Impulse and the Mystery of Golgotha (Part II)
Matching lines:

But now we must turn our minds to something else which was mentioned
many Mystics that one must remove oneself from God in order to be able
Certainly many Mystics have maintained that one must withdraw from God
giving a knowledge of life. This knowledge of life must remain the
secret of birth, the secret of Man's becoming, so must they and all
This is the new and important fact which we must transform into a
way. If one wants to understand the evolution of mankind, one must
understand that Michael too has evolved: one must understand that it
Earth, so we must ‘feel’ in quite a concrete way the
asleep; we must feel and know how there lives in this spiritual world
mankind will be rightly seen in the picture of the Dragon that must be
again, which for earlier times had another meaning and which must now

Title: Lecture: Michaelmas VIII: The Michael Path to the Christ (Extract)
Matching lines:

way that mankind must become related to him. For now Michael is not
we must approach the Christ-impulse through Michael. In many respects
To-day it is Christ Jesus whom we must strive to find through Michael,
that we must seek for feelings and ideas which have nothing to do with
cannot be found on the surface. They must be sought where the spirit
Spiritual Science. The matter lies thus; that we must resolve to seek

Title: Threefold Order: Part II: Lecture: The Impulse Towards the Threefold Order
Matching lines:

speaking to-day as one must, if one speaks from the way of
evolution must go forward of itself; that Man is tied and bound
Labour and of that, which must really lie below the cry
working-classes, then these Works' Councils must grow up on the
saying that the corporate body of Works' Councils must grow out
that was produced must be paid as dues to the landlord; and
must come, is one who hears the cry that goes up from the whole
the old system of capital and wages, must give place to
clear, that along with capital the wage-system itself must go;
and that there must come a free communal association of the
We must start from this important truth: that we
the Rights arising from the means of production; and we must
of production are in no way commodities, but must pass from man
really social thinking in every people must lead to a
of Works' Councils must go out solely from the economic body
Works' Councils. It must come out of the forces of the economic
this means, that we must give our minds in deepest earnest to
the body social must be placed on its three proper footings!

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture I: Introduction - Aphoristic remarks on Artistic Activity, Arithmetic, Reading, and Writing
Matching lines:

assumptions than those which we must make. Our methods are not
realize the course which must be taken by education itself for
entity. We must be aware that other practices of our physical
which we must call artistic, we enter with them into the sphere
‘fish.’ We now try to show the child that he must only begin
artistic element. Therefore we must begin, in teaching to
simply appealed to perception. So we must not only think
in abstracto. We must teach art in
drawing, etc.; we must impart the psychic element in teaching
arithmetic, and we must teach the conventional element of
reading and writing artistically; we must permeate our whole
only that the artistic element must be cultivated, too, but the
whole of our teaching must be drawn from the artistic element.
All method must be immersed in the artistic element.
Education and teaching must become a real art. Here, too,
knowledge must not be more than the underlying basis.
all, in principle — and must, in spite of it, pass on,
must go on to make the child understand that grown-up people,
otherwise only survey with the eye. We must endeavour to
into the separate addenda, so that we must teach the child to
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture II: On Language - the Oneness of man with the Universe
Matching lines:

must think of each separate system as repeated again in the
ourselves, if, that is, we have the feeling that we must put up
sympathy with its object. In considering these facts you must
which I have mentioned, you must remember that they are valid
must be sought out as shades of feeling.
Consonants fbm, etc., must be sought out as imitations
If we take this day, to have a corresponding year we must
beings. We must say, then: “We are earthly beings through
cosmos. We must permeate our whole education with this
before he was born or conceived. This feeling must arise from a
consideration of vowels and consonants. This feeling must
checked or cultivated — must be pursued in education with
true; only you must understand it rightly. You must establish
these antipathies on the proper footing. You must try to
children now. And we must cultivate sympathies in the right way
But you must try to penetrate to every side of the human being.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture III: On the Plastically Formative Arts, Music, and Poetry
Matching lines:

see, further, that teaching must be managed so as always to
which must be transmuted into something living. When we
give rise to. For this reason we must not be afraid of
aims and ultimate achievement of Eurhythmy. It must,
ourselves from this dying. You must beware of wanting to reduce
educators. Now you must not say: “We are not to cultivate
therefore we must beware of them. But that would be equivalent
cultivation of the conceptual element; we must cultivate it,
but at the same time we must not neglect to approach human
Then we ourselves must be very profoundly convinced that mere
it should be fashioned; we should feel the chair; it must not
only be beautiful; its nature must be to be sat on. The whole
There must, therefore, be no reservations with the
must there be reservations in the true experience of that
early to this experience. But, in a sense, even this must
understand, which must first mature, is extraordinarily
deadening element into our pedagogy. But the child must know
within the child that he must be ready to wait for a perfect
the child's comprehension must be overthrown. It can naturally
only be done with tact, for we must not depart too far from
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture IV: The First School-lesson - Manual Skill, Drawing and Painting - the Beginnings of Language-teaching
Matching lines:

must look on the first school-lesson which you take with your
school must be consciously appreciated. “You have come to
much this shade of feeling must remain a nuance of feeling and
sentiment, it must nevertheless be cultivated in the
children by all possible means: the child must look up with
culture must be inspired in the child from the very first, so
must try to continue the already suggested conversation with
or when you want to buy clothes or make clothes.” We must
nature of man. The child must not only know that he has hands,
but he must be conscious that he has hands. Of course you will
into play. The greatest value must not first of all be attached
then you must ask: “Peter, what is that?” “A
You must attach importance to do habitually the proper thing in
like it. Each child must leave a certain space between his and
course, fully justified. Only it must not therefore be imagined
of address of which we must become conscious by all means. When
kind of healing or restoration of the soul's being must take
All this, however, is only by way of preliminary; it must be
the structure of our language. But besides this, we must
must be profoundly conscious that the power of articulate
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture V: Writing and Reading - Spelling
Matching lines:

will just get the beginning clear: ‘B.’” The child must
“fish.” And now it must be made clear to the child
And from these two points of view both life and teaching must
be considered. For you must ask yourself: “What is more
with living reality. But you must never omit to write up the
you must always be careful to explain the accompanying sounds,
vowels must always be made to render the human inner being and
what he did. If he does not, if nobody remembers, you must
he did: how he must have stood, what he must have said if the
sunrise was very beautiful: “Ah!” You must let this
echo of emotion resound; you must try to derive the resonance,
which we hear in the vowel, from emotion. And then you must try
develop as individuals must be sacrificed where we have to meet
is to receive him, that therefore he must respect what is
already there. From this point of view, too, we must try to
spelling we must cultivate in him the feeling of respect, of
reverence, for what our forefathers have settled. And we must
though it came from the Absolute — but you must develop
in the child the feeling that the grown-ups, whom one must
That is what I meant when I said: “The transition must be
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture VI: On the Rhythm of Life and Rhythmical Repetition in Teaching
Matching lines:

even merely demurring. Consequently, I must introduce into
carrying out their experiments there. But we must consider for
procedure because it must be mentioned in view of the
way, and its one-sidedness must, of course, be counterbalanced.
passage if you want to learn it easily. And here I must make
educationist: It is to some extent self-evident that one must
that with the child, too, we must study subjects which do not
unable to enter into their meaning, for that must only dawn
should do; that is what you must do. You must try first of all
hand you must also give the child things which can have some
must definitely practise subjects concerned with revealing
we must cultivate everything which does not aim at a mere
subtlety of education which must absolutely be respected,
consciousness. But the educator must, after all, take up a
position outside ordinary life to some extent. He must not be
thing of the past. It is a good thing. But it must be a thing
of the past in other senses, too; it must in future be a thing
extent, but it must be bound up with a profounder conception of
educator must be able to study life more profoundly, otherwise
certain degree every teacher must know truths which he cannot
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture VII: The Teaching in the Ninth Year - Natural History - the Animal Kingdom
Matching lines:

to-day about the transition in method which must be attended to
history. You must know, in the meantime, that in man we have,
At this point you must not go any further, for the limbs are
to work. In short, the child's attention must be clearly
must be clear as to how to proceed. You will try to familiarize
cuttle-fish. You must try to develop this artistic feeling in
With the cuttle-fish you must suggest how it feels its
translate it into teaching, for you must first be conscious of
what you must later introduce less consciously into
able to gnaw at objects, as it must, to nourish itself, and
means of its head, man cannot do this. The head must be poised
move freely in the water. You must at least succeed in giving
head. And you must awaken in the children a feeling for the
must then awaken in the child a feeling of the external feature
will-element, must first have developed — you can see
teacher must pay attention to it. For his reason you will be
has been reached — to natural history, which must always
possibilities?” But we must first know them, if all the

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture VIII: Education After the Twelfth - History - Physics
Matching lines:

external legislation, we must obviously agree to compromise
curriculum. But we must keep clear what are the right and good
there must still be taken into account the reciprocal relation
of man to his surroundings, that attention must be paid to man
crusader, or of other heroes, you must now try to recast these,
form an image upon the back wall of the eye, etc. You must
a human sense-organ. If you want to do this you must already
respond. That is, you must have already shown the child the
for the whole of life. You will therefore find that you must
all such things. But you must not explain to him before he is
habitual actions. But because of this we must not keep too
tendency always to rise and the cold air must then fall, so
but to do this I must always be careful to wipe the objects
which are to be electrified, for they must be dry. If they are
reason we must at least see that what we consciously teach the
this involves. You must cultivate in yourself the capacity for
no matter what the subject. You must not let yourself be
way.” No, you must have the gift of so transforming
this properly you must penetrate a little deeper into human
nature. We must take seriously the fact that man must become
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture IX: On the Teaching of Languages
Matching lines:

intended to illustrate this or that rule. Only you must so
grammatical teaching the examples must be dropped and in no
must remain. For this reason you do well in the living
in living conclusions, and these must not lapse into the
dreaminess of habit, but must always be a part of fully
air, you must realize that they feel little inclination, after
did in romping about. But you must take care, too, to think out
examples of this kind, and must not omit to give the child this
about it at table. But you must really say things which the
These things can be done, but you yourself must take part in
children must get out the books or exercise-books for Latin or
French; then they must have done their “prep.”; now
they must translate; now they are to read. By this time
must obviously see to it that the grammar and syntax teaching
which you intend to use, but you must have the skill to call

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture X: Arranging the Lesson up to the Fourteenth Year
Matching lines:

we must be clear in our minds that we have already crossed the
civilization. At this stage these foreign languages must only
must carefully take into account, when we organize our school,
understand. We shall definitely make this discovery and must
mind of the teacher must do its quite peculiar work. You must
memory, you must link every lesson in the foreign language,
other hand, the points learnt from these sentences must be
For we must know what makes the teaching of a foreign language
in a foreign language greater regard must be paid to making
does belong there, for the child must learn this art of
achieve this aim we must begin with childhood. And for this
own. But we must convert the intellectually minded age
back to the will-element. For this reason we must notice
These, again, are things which you must think over and absorb,
and which you must take especially into account in teaching
to make them banal. The child must never have the feeling that
different colours. The separate surfaces must be coloured and

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture XI: On the Teaching of Geography
Matching lines:

senior schools (age 12-18) — we must see that geography
understand this aspect we must not fail to pursue it. And last
have it laid down beforehand: geography must be taught from
completely, excludes the teacher's art. And this must not be.
The teacher must be the driving and stimulating element in the
by building it up from the separate animals. We must treat the
here you must not omit — again connecting mineralogy with
the suggestions of past lessons. We must simply have a good

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture XII: How to Connect School with Practical Life
Matching lines:

must not close our minds to
sense, if we are to be true educators and teachers, we must
(seven to nine, nine to twelve, twelve to fourteen). We must
and spirit. In fact, people must benumb themselves to escape
must always remain a matter of great satisfaction to see people
functions of the outside world. The child must leave with a
This ideal of unity, inspiring the human soul, must
whole world must be alive. In every vocation there must exist
almost inapplicable to that vocation. People must be interested
teaching, must be clearly kept in mind, and what the child
learns at thirteen, fourteen, and fifteen must be given less of
a sentimental turn; on the contrary, it must be directed into
things must be noticed which unfortunately cannot in our case
be observed in the course of religious instruction. We must not
and don't care two pins for anything else. No, we must
interesting chapter. People's thoughts must be directed
about. Above all, people must know that the human being is a
cultivate in him must often be prepared beforehand.

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture XIII: On Drawing up the Time-table
Matching lines:

on different occasions already that we must agree, with regard
will result for us in the most vital difficulties which we must
beginning and end of the school years. We must do our utmost to
do justice to our ideal time-table, and we must do our utmost
above all we must seek to include in the first school year a
Then, indeed, we must make room for something which would be
Anthroposophy.” For this reason we must take care that
the child can distinguish vowels from consonants. We must
self-contained objects. You must try here to say to him:
training, of course, is quite good, but one must be aware that
see in this connection we must naturally pay great attention to
we must pay heed when we are concerned with the right treatment
child must feel: when he speaks Greek he really only speaks
language. I must draw the child's attention to this. Then I

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Lecture XIV: Moral Educative Principles and their Transition to Practice
Matching lines:

Central Europe — must approach the curriculum with a
the moral tendencies which must be the basis of all pedagogy.
his body. When the child leaves school you must have enabled
comes upon the individual he loses his food-instincts; he must
must save them up for the last school years, when the fire of
that much of our teaching must contain such vitality that it
You must try to teach, not only graphically, but with vivid
plant world. These ideas of things must be rooted in feeling
history and botany — too obvious. We must avoid drawing
the twilight instincts of the soul, which we must overcome by
this stage it must be remembered that man has an instinct for
etc., which appeals to the instincts. But we must be sure to
consequently we must use this stage of development for studying
must absorb these facts quite completely into your being as
We must never forget, you see, that mere observation and
materialistic spirit of our age. Naturally, observation must be
cultivated in its proper place, but you must not apply the

Title: Practical Course/Teachers: Concluding Remarks
Matching lines:

that the teacher is a person of initiative, that he must never
be slack; but must put his whole being into what he does in
thing: The teacher must be an individual of initiative in
“The second is that as teachers we must take an interest
and mankind. As teachers we must be interested in all worldly
second thing: The teacher must be interested in every aspect
“And the third thing is: The teacher must be an
teacher must be profoundly and inwardly true, he must never
also a golden rule for the teacher's work: The teacher must
not dry up and not become soured; he must have an
un-withered, fresh disposition of the soul. He must not get
dry, and he must not get sour. To the very contrary is what the
teacher must aspire.
“But you must think ever and again over the suggestions
initiating and organizing it. This Waldorf School must succeed.

Title: Study of Man: Lecture I
Matching lines:

depends on his thoughts about the world. Children must learn to
must always set humanity fresh tasks. The task of mankind in the first
second, and so on down to our fifth Post-Atlantean epoch. And we must
task at the outset. We must learn to understand that we have to give a
must remember) the education, or mis-education given them by their
the child's life. For this we must fill ourselves with the
We live in a time when this appeal to human egoism must be combated in
further on its present downward course. We must become more and more
birth. We must consciously face this fact: that man evolves through a
questions must come to a stop somewhere in reality. If we remain in
Beings who stand above the physical. It is to them that we must leave
Now when the child has come forth on to the physical plane, we must
spiritual to a physical plane. Firstly, we must recognise that the
which we must now work our way through. And between death and a new
into harmony with the Life-Body. They must come into harmony with
one another. They must be attuned to one another; for when the child
world and the human being who is entering it. But we must also be
have to do with the child. We must first gain an
this must be taken in hand, in order that a harmony may thereby be
this that a rightly guided education must accomplish: it must enable
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Study of Man: Lecture II
Matching lines:

In the future all teaching must be founded on a real psychology —
instruction and education generally must be built up on psychology,
Let us look at what is ordinarily called mental picture. We must
this end we must first of all gain a clear conception of the mental
Now when you consider the image character of mental picturing you must
above all think of it qualitatively. You must consider its mobility,
much the impression of being, of existence, and we must realise that
images must be images of something; they cannot be merely images as
picturing is of this image nature, we must next ask: of what is it an
diagrammatically you must mentally picture the course of your life to
You must then further represent to yourself that mental picturing is
We must now investigate will in the same way. For the ordinary
hand, which we must conceive of as an image from pre-natal life; and
will, on the other hand, which we must conceive of as the seed of
seed. Now we must ask: what are the forces that really bring this
We must be quite clear that in man there are certain forces which
but must perish at the moment it arises; it has to remain as a seed,
and the seed must not evolve too far. Thus it must perish in the
human being. You must learn to understand the whole man, spirit, soul
You must not introduce too many abstract concepts into what you bring
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Study of Man: Lecture III
Matching lines:

But I must point out that in future everything in the sphere of
teaching must be on an equal footing; and public opinion will have to
as with older — there must be something that one cannot of course
dying. This is a law of extraordinary importance. You must be very
question must be asked: how would it be with the world if man himself
must be clear that not only the lower animal forms but also the plant
by man, the evolution of the earth cannot endure. We must now permeate

Title: Study of Man: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

Teacher must understand hidden being of man. Marxist education
new educational impulse, that special attention must be paid, in
childhood, notice must be taken of this part of the will which
education, we must pay heed to this embryonic form of the spirit in
it lives in the body, then we must speak of the three soul principles
can apprehend. We must know that just as the soul of man is clothed
When we want to study the will, we must first seek it in the sphere of
instinct and we must be aware that we find instinct in the forms of
sounding quietly in the depths, and this gentle undertone must now be
To be a teacher and educator one must work with what is taking place
life, it must come forth from an understanding of the inner man.
vanish from the face of the earth. Some people must see this. You have
We must take great care that there are men who know that progress in
of the human being in the sphere of education. Hence it must be known
that the educator and the teacher of the future must understand the
innermost being of man, must live with this inner being and that the
(the sleeping quarters were only a few paces away). Of course we must
must realise that a child has to develop quite different powers of
each other. Thus education must be able to reach the depths of the
soul; otherwise no progress will be made. Hence we must ask ourselves:
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Study of Man: Lecture V
Matching lines:

different senses. Reality must be won through work.
Now there is one thing that we must be clear about, and this I have
But now we must also learn the special nature of the activities of
cognition. We have already spoken of this, but we must be fully
demands of the world, for example in social life. We must permeate our
which the teacher and educator must bring to full consciousness. In
remain in this condition, it must be permeated with thought, by idea,
it must be continuously illumined as it were by the conscious mental
These instincts must become antipathetic to us; we must pour antipathy
somewhat ascetic. But this asceticism must be rightly understood. It
judgment, which must of course form an opinion upon something quite
objective. The fact that man should be good must not be dependent on
our subjective feeling. The content of the judgment must be objective.
must first receive them consciously into our soul. And we cannot
co-operation of feeling. Therefore, we must say that Brentano and
convinced of the rightness of the judgment, feeling must develop.
to day. One must rise to a different level before one can reach such
highest type of music must consist solely in the tone-picture, the
at their deepest in the sphere of education. Therefore we must strive

Title: Study of Man: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

the education of the child. We must keep the three standpoints
view you must return again and again to the separation of man's soul
concepts): when you have knowledge through thought you must feel that
“That man is a good man,” thus forming a judgment. You must
dreaminess. This must be an incentive to you to work upon such
child is destined not to appear until later, then he must be treated
be that he is not that at all. And you must know how to awaken the
will in a child of this kind. That means that you must work into his
element. You must treat a child of this kind by building as little as
not look at the world superficially we must recognise that our whole
it and in the midst of which it is placed. This ego must still be
above is not correct) you must draw it in the following way, and then
parts of your body, you carry your head. Now the head must be able to
thinking-cognition. It must be withdrawn from the sleeping-willing;

Title: Study of Man: Lecture VII
Matching lines:

the human being from the spiritual point of view, we must lay
clearly before you. Only you must take into account that in this
argument, then, we must be quite clear that in old age men become wise
and life power for their spirit, we must recognise the beginnings of
Now we must take notice that something arises straight-away whenever
single observations within it. Thus you must seek the best in the
willing-feeling or feeling-willing. Therefore we must say that where
You must seek out the sphere of willing and feeling in the child's
while educating intellect we must also work continually on the will.
For in all that the child looks at and perceives we must also
pensioned off. We must get away from the words and come to the spirit
of things. If we want to understand something we must not immediately
think of the word each time, but we must seek the real connections. If
spaces are. We must be grateful to the nerve system that it does not
Now you must attend very carefully to what I am going to say, and
must also bring the time element of his life into relationship with
our times. But the teacher must understand also the times in which he

Title: Study of Man: Lecture VIII
Matching lines:

open to outer observation. You will see from this that it must be our
naturally not be able to do this in a day. We must so plan our lessons
his memory. In other words, you must understand how everything that
power of the memory must be derived from the feeling and will and not
reality of human nature, we must be clear that all separation proceeds
you, you must really lay aside all pedantry, otherwise you may perhaps
me and the other man. Hence I must realise that the perception of my
of knowledge, but I must know that this process of knowledge is only a
spoken speech. Speech only mediates for the thoughts. You must
component parts, and the human being must attain the power to re-unite
Let us be quite clear about this; to know the human being you must
must be grasped by means of conditions of consciousness such as

Title: Study of Man: Lecture IX
Matching lines:

knowledge must be truly real, which means it must rest upon a true
We must be clear that a spiritual conception of man makes it necessary
Therefore in dealing with children of primary school age we must
about logic must be kept in the background. For logic is, of course,
something pre-eminently scientific; it must be brought to the children
menagerie is the drawing of a conclusion. We must be clear on this
teach the children to form judgments. You must be absolutely aware of
authority, must always be conscious that what he says will become part
Now, to come from judgment to concept: we must realise that when we
must learn from these things what is really necessary in the
life. That is to say, you must take great care to talk over with the
children? It must be a living concept if man has to live with it. Man
is alive, thus the concept must also be alive. If in the child's ninth
You must give the child such concepts as are capable of change in his
later life. The educator must aim at giving the child concepts which
teaching. What then must we do? In teaching we must not make
definitions but rather must endeavour to make characterisations. We
day, then we are really only defining the animal for him. We must try
and does not dry up and become hard and rigid. You must therefore
Therefore you must realise that you have to give the child things
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Study of Man: Lecture X
Matching lines:

Teacher must understand man as microcosm.
First we will recall — what must have struck us from various
fragment of a sphere is contained. We must consequently, allow that
parts. We must always interweave one thing with another; for this is
world, you must study the arms and legs, hands and feet. If you want
to study how the intelligence of the world is revealed, then you must
study the head, or rather the skull, as skeleton; you must see how the
upper and lower jaws are attached to the head, and you must examine
bone. You must turn the inside outwards and the outside inwards and
other lectures that you must think of the limbs as inserted into the
shoulders and does not let the movements reach the soul. The soul must
must learn man's relationship to the spirit, and through it to the
the human being, must be in a position to grasp the fundamentals of
In another connection I said how it must always fill us with wonder
the children as a whole. Pedagogy in the true sense must be built on
feelings such as this. Pedagogy must not be a science, it must be an
constantly in the feelings? But the feelings in which we must live in

Title: Study of Man: Lecture XI
Matching lines:

and a spirit that is still asleep. Now we must see how we can bring
brilliance and ability to yourselves. But you must of course be ready
someone who has greater possibilities than he. We must of course
must strive to the uttermost. Our pupil may become better than we are,
depths, is the awakener of the human spirit in the child. We must
milk we must say: when milk is produced it seeks to be the awakener of
Here we must indeed be clear that it is only certain definite things
that in good teaching reading and writing must only be given by way of
art. The first elements of drawing, painting and music must precede
years when the child is first given into our charge, we must teach him
You must bear in mind that the child you are teaching and educating
work. The child has to grow. Yes, he must grow, and while educating
him you should realise that he must grow rightly. What does this mean?
It means that you must not by your teaching, by your education,
disturb the child's growth. You must not effect a disturbance of his
through breathing, nourishment, movement, and the like. And you must
— but you have it. Thus you must have insight into the conditions
of human growth. You must have this insight from the point of view of
point of view of the soul? For this we must turn to a better kind of
forces of life development in man. And we must acquire the power of
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Study of Man: Lecture XII
Matching lines:

When we consider the human body, we must relate it to the physical
immediately evident to superficial observation; we must penetrate
build up our truly human shape? No, indeed it does not. You must learn
must immediately send it out again so that he may not become a plant.
must be sought in this tendency towards plant growth in man. Naturally
Thus if we look at the whole plant world of man's environment we must
chest-trunk system, at least in its initial stages, and must be
it. The beginning and the end of the process of combustion must never
strong country people for instance, then he must be very closely
it. Thus he cannot take part in the end stage either. He must excrete
adequately apply the antidote which we must find in connection with
take place in it: when we know that the human being must dissolve
within him the mineral, must reverse within him the plant kingdom,
must raise above him, that is, must spiritualise, the animal kingdom.

Title: Study of Man: Lecture XIII
Matching lines:

the limb man is in complete contrast to that of the head man. We must
destructiveness of the spirit. And in man a balance must be created
significance. We must realise that if we allow the child to accumulate
must understand this paradox and make it our own, namely that bodily
We must know such things, my dear friends, if we are to think with
purpose — these words must sink into our minds if we would be
accordance with those of his own body. We must pay heed to this where
excessive tendency to fat. We must not entirely neglect the bodily
side, for man must live in rhythm, but having swung over to this side
we must swing back again to a kind of movement which is permeated with
One must speak of these things to-day in this radical manner because
the present-day teacher must understand them; for, not only must he be
the teacher of those children entrusted to his care, he must also work
socially, he must work back upon mankind as a whole to prevent the
disorder into our normal life. This must be specially borne in mind
must feel it our duty to ask ourselves: why should the child undergo a
conditions this must remain an ideal for the time being. And I must
outside world. Your criticism of our present-day civilisation you must
But you must always remember the inner connection of things. You must
We must bring spirit into external work, and we must bring blood into

Title: Study of Man: Lecture XIV
Matching lines:

time we must recognise that the limb formation is much more
legs and feet, and your arms and hands. Only you must think of the
Where do these jaws bite? Where is the mouth?” And you must
human trunk (see drawing) you must think of the real head as somewhere
skeletal system. But it must be a skeletal system of the soul. To
achieve this we must now leave off developing language merely at
random through imitation, and must devote our powers to the
rightful expression after puberty. This must be known.
power of imagination that we must especially appeal in the latter part
that the power of judgment gradually develops.) We must arouse the
learn during these years; all history, all geography teaching must be
must consistently appeal to the imagination. We appeal to the
imagination between teacher and child. The teacher must keep alive all
he must shape his teaching material afresh every time. For in actual
up. Of necessity imagination must always be kept living, otherwise its
This, in turn, throws light on what the teacher must be himself. He
must never for a single moment in his life get sour. And if life is to
be fruitful, two things must never meet, namely, the teaching vocation
wicked and immoral. This must be the teacher's attitude of mind. If it
and make them part of yourself, You must know, for example, that the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture I
Matching lines:

course in anthroposophy, must fight for its validity in the
however, that spiritual science must fight, if one takes into
mathematics must be introduced. Through this, one feels
acknowledge the necessity that a spiritual science must come
in order also to secure certainty of understanding? One must
first questions that must occupy us is this: What is the
saying this, I must emphasize that spiritual science has
way. This effort is in the character of our time and must be
then one must accept the outer expression of the inner
these experiments must be explained in a spiritual sense.
of the soul life. But to explain such facts one must know how
what is investigated experimentally must be permeated with
We must,
We must acquire some thoughts about what we are doing when we
we must say: Out there are the material facts; we arrange
what our soul-constitution must be in acquiring knowledge of
the outer world! We are in the position where we must tell
consists of two stages: First we must look at the empirical
basically lost the fullness of the outer world. One must,
One must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture II
Matching lines:

kind of metabolic activity. One must be clear about the fact
our soul organization relate to one another. We must also go
precisely, not in dilettante fashion. One must know these
interpretation of the total act of seeing must be accepted
the bodily aspect of seeing — here the cerebrum must
life. But we must not overlook the fact that this judging of
dimension while we walk is almost imperceptible, we must not
addition we must establish an activity that creates the third

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture III
Matching lines:

must be willing to observe the way this science actually
It must first
cognition actually is. For this we must return to an earlier
that certain things are hidden there which we must assume to
concern must be that everything that leads to an imaginative
I must raise
capacity must first be developed. It is also not strange that
developed further. Now, however, we must ask ourselves if
someone is correct who says, "Yes, but the relationship must
descriptive way, even though it must really be regarded as a
But it must be

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

reason it must always be emphasized that in order to speak of
the earth as an organism, for example, one must first speak
the word) as the salt does. It must develop on the rosebush.
we must take care not to theorize about the observations
to do this we must exert a distinct effort to raise
system, we must attain a higher level of knowledge. (The word
"higher" is of course just a term.) Above all I must
consciousness by voluntary effort. The soul must really exert
thought); now through further exertion we must be able
"enhanced forgetting" must be especially cultivated.
enhanced forgetting — we must be careful to avoid
— living our lives as human beings, we must admit that
Then we must look at our outer experiences: what confronts us
scientist must take his development in hand through a certain
achieve a healthy experience in this region we must know that
often we must use words that already have older meanings. So
realm of feeling. This leads us to something I must
what modern man must develop in a soul-spiritual way —

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture V
Matching lines:

an unsolved remainder. For this reason we must develop our
system, we must simply say: in its origin and development,
methodical work. This stage we must of course leave behind
must be led over to something pictorial, something evoked
preparation, but in this regard we must just register the
As a breathing organism, we must feel the same way. We are
rituals, one must look at their inner nature. It was not out
in the usual external way. One must enter deeply into man's
being and must consider how the various functions of the

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

memory process, and then we must distill out what can be
tendency and the falsifying tendency, and that we must be
Certainly we must be aware of how memory is transformed by
else. This must happen in such a way that the original power
increasing the power of our soul. For what is it that we must
what should not be the case; we must be in a position to hold
speaks of a Kantian “thing in itself” that must
next step: we must practice again and again eliminating these
inward upon our memories, we must admit that having the
knowledge and not mystical intoxication, one must strive
cosmos. It is connected with the cosmos. I must look toward
just as I must look toward the cosmos and the make-up of the
in the form intended at that time, one must have certain experiences
of inner vision. One must first be able to take what one
this, one must hold one's inner forces firmly together if one
is to accomplish it. One must, in fact, repeatedly resolve to
gets something not right. One must overcome the inward
investigator has moments when he must wrestle with certain
practical activities. These activities must of course be
before you just as an example of how spiritual science must

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture VII
Matching lines:

must be continued in such a way that one really forgets
process of spiritual research. With every step one must be
two completely different contents that must be reconciled
human organism must relate itself to receiving something like
in a serious and exact manner. At the same time, it must be
must be inwardly worked upon. As perception is worked upon by
us as does perception. It must be penetrated by inner
perceptions must be penetrated by mathematical thinking. In
short, our ordinary experience must be penetrated by our
forgetting comes about which I must characterize as a
intuitively. I must describe this in the following way.
One must be
I confess I am not finished with it yet but must pursue it a
What is presented there must naturally
with this degree of emphasis, one must have a certain level
He said to himself: Something must be at work here. This is
according to the forces I already know, so there must be
the outer configuration what must have been there to form the
appeared that must be accepted objectively. Through a living
guests! I know just how much these lectures must seem
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Anthroposophy Science: Lecture VIII
Matching lines:

participants in these lectures have worked hard, we must also
conditions, anyone who understands the situation must feel:
human being, then it must be able to prove itself in the
must have their truth proven by its fruitfulness. We can
separate disciplines must work together in the process of
general human evolution, and must spring from a common
spiritual-scientific reasons I must speak about two Jesus
knowledge we believe there is another need. Something must be
however, that certain scientific elements still lacking must
in a calm and objective way. For we must not hide the fact

Title: Dear Children: Lecture I: Address at the Christmas Assembly
Matching lines:

good will in the children of the Waldorf School. Our concern must be

Title: Dear Children: Lecture II: Address at a Monthly Assembly
Matching lines:

you again and again. You must answer me; this is what I am most
Oh, there is something I must tell you —

Title: Dear Children: Lecture III: Address at the Assembly at the End of the First School Year
Matching lines:

be human beings at all. The spirit must be educated so that we become
flower! Now I guess I must wash myself and dry my hands, and perhaps
something that I am convinced that people today must start to believe
You see, dear children, you must

Title: Awakening to Community: Lecture I
Matching lines:

spiritual world to partake of their content. Anthroposophy must bring
speak about these matters as I must, in duty bound.
education best serve human growth? Anthroposophy must show how this
anthroposophy to be rightly creative in the various fields, it must
various spheres of culture and civilization. The Society must unite
child, it must be clearly recognized that the child cannot prosper if
Society to justify any thought of rebuilding the Goetheanum. We must
one's fellow men that are an outgrowth of it anthroposophy. Must it
virtues, and it is essential that it strive to acquire them. It must
young, the old, the middle-aged. We must be an anthroposophical
offspring. This is something of which we must be keenly aware. Though
change our ways before it is too late, as it soon may be. We must
Society, every specialist must join forces with everybody else.

Title: Awakening to Community: Lecture II
Matching lines:

case. A world view such as that based on anthroposophy must always be
to be sure they are one's own. One must be equally sure, before
been discarded. I must therefore emphasize — and I bring up
cannot progress. But the work must progress; otherwise, we would
in the book mentioned. So I must point out how out of place it is to
must stay away from it and let it live all to itself. Thus the ego
super-sensible things that is to find valid expression must be sent to
other areas today, but that one must think differently, feel
without anthroposophy. I must stress this in a time of crisis for our
I must add here that
But when harmful things happen I must be allowed to exercise my own
judgment about bringing them up. Complete independence must be the
freedom and pure concepts, must be permeated by the Christ impulse.
just because the various evolutionary impulses of the human race must
gradually be saturated by the Christ impulse. Man must learn to think
itself in the spirit, its true home. We must learn, on the

Title: Awakening to Community: Lecture III
Matching lines:

it must be pointed out that by reducing the earth to a mere grain of
merely to knowledge that must be accepted on someone else's authority
earthly life must be regarded as the soul corpse of the living soul
is the point, and a point that must be sharply stressed if the
said in my first lecture here, we must realize that anthroposophy is
the guiding elements in the Society must become aware that if the
Society is to earn its name in future, they must make themselves
movements must work together to achieve this goal. We cannot rest
been neglected in favor of various offspring movements. It must be

Title: Awakening to Community: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

practical situation prevailing in the life around them must be taken
they are honest. But we must admit, too, that the very clarity
with the life about him, as indeed he must, his real desire is to
will impulses inward, he must, in other words, strive for the kind of
us. They throw light, however, on the question of what must be done
Movement's first phase. This is a capacity one must work to develop.
long-latent conflict. It must be brought out into the open and
suffers from two evils, both of which must be overcome in the
books bring in money and appear on book lists. There must be themes
held that man was born evil and must overcome his nature, the
often nothing more than pretense. I must add that both these ominous
anthroposophical life must overcome. If this anthroposophical life is
to develop in a practical direction, everything it undertakes must be
enterprises are outgrowths of anthroposophy. This must be kept firmly
men and other such specialists simply must not turn their backs on

Title: Awakening to Community: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

and to feel the intimate connection with it just described. We must,
we are now shelterless, we must seek the more intensively for a
shelter in our hearts that will replace the one we have lost, We must
description of the conditions that must prevail in anthroposophical
years ago. We must guard against any such misconceptions as these as
weighty word has already been uttered here on that score. But we must
far. Are we to forget the depths for the surface? That must not be
movement. I said that a suitable method of community building must be
the social community is reduced to atoms. This must be easy to see
are living in a time when human nature must go on to develop the
consciousness soul, must become ever more conscious.
seems like people's own naive experiencing and feeling. We must make
grasp the further element that must come to play a corresponding role
soul-spiritual element in our fellowmen. But we must first learn to
no matter how mundane the setting. We must be able to feel that
conviction of this; it must be inwardly experienced, so that we do
and having our own thoughts about it. A real spiritual being must be
attitudes must learn similarly to invoke the presence of a real
must so attune our speaking, our feeling, our thinking, our impulses
We must make
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Awakening to Community: Lecture VII
Matching lines:

an entirely different way than one looks at the sense world. One must
share a life with others in an ordinary state of waking, so must
it simply cannot be done in the spiritual realm. There, the soul must
be imbued with the most perfect tolerance; one must educate oneself
but do not undertake to transform their souls as these must be
investigator must either assume the burden of defending himself
based is anthroposophy, that foundation must now be defended by
These facts must be
from my intention. But the spirit that must inspire us in
must be aware of the matters discussed today in relation to the
Anthroposophical Society's life and progress. They must all be taken
difficulties that have proliferated are a consequence of what I must
— a fact that must be stressed again and again. These
how each such difficulty originated. And it must be emphasized that
pointed out in this and similar connections that we must distinguish
but they must nevertheless be sharply differentiated.
friends, are the things that must become matters of clear and
experience and physical reality must be kept separate in ordinary

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 1 (Summary): Effects of Modern Agnosticism
Matching lines:

this must for ever remain hidden from human wisdom; and most especially
of the truths which must live in art.

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 2 (Summary): Perception and Thinking
Matching lines:

in which we are wide awake, in which we must actually be when it comes

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 3 (Summary): The Tragedy of F. Nietzsche
Matching lines:

observable, so must psychic-spiritual facts be accessible to spiritual
then has disowned it. But the way of observing it must be conducted
relying on sensory experience, as in observing nature, we must look out
world. Thinking itself must bring about the state of freedom, in that it
We must, above all else,
If men remain men, then must they be overcome by pain. Therefore must
One must come to an

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 4 (Summary): The Relationship between Goethe and Hegel
Matching lines:

into the spiritual worlds. All investigation must be formed on monistic
answer. He shows that nature must be understood poetically, for art
must perceive this ‘germ soul.’ There is consequently a
out the springs of Spiritual Science, it must always be referred to
that other fount. Agnostic methods of thinking must be put aside in

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 5: From Sense Perception to Spirit Imaging
Matching lines:

of everyday consciousness. There must be nothing overwhelming, and what
of destiny. And this brings me to a point where a distinction must be
it must be regarded, by anyone following the path of knowledge with

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 6: From Imaginative Knowledge to Inspirational Knowledge
Matching lines:

not be misinterpreted. In the first place it must really come as a surprise
as individual concepts we must link up ourselves. The feeling we gradually
of growth. We realize that we must reject a vital force arrived at through
taken to reach Imagination must never aim for a reduced level of conscious
awareness. Our goal must be achieved purely in the sphere of mind and
are related, but we must get a really clear idea of the path to imaginative
This must lead to the ability to reject and, in the final instance,
we must come to know, and then we progress from Imagination to knowledge
and we must not copy it. It would cast us down into the physical organization.
something must have changed. The definition of young Miller at seven
And in the same way we must also come to see how thought becomes will,
It must of course

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 7: The Gulf Between a Causal Explanation of Nature and the Moral World Order
Matching lines:

the ethical views that may be held today, and on the other it must consider
are consistent in our methods: We must not stop when it comes to the
man must consider connected with all of his rank and dignity, all of
of faith; he must come to acknowledge this realm out of the subjective
whole range of faculties in the human soul and spirit — we must
also of all moral ideals. Those must disappear into a state of non-being
it must have an effect on his deepest feelings. In the realm of man's
existence that counts, the only valid form of existence. Matter must
it is valid there must be a power that destroys its validity. This power
which all inclination must fade into silence, even though it run counter

Title: Fruits/Anthroposophy: Lecture 8: The Social Question
Matching lines:

in the consciousness on which ordinary science is based. We must, however,
himself must above all see to it that he holds in full awareness to
must proceed as follows. We cannot in that case produce all kinds of
science specifically demands that the study of external nature must
social order, an order that he must create very consciously today, which
inferior which we must rise above. Oh yes, if we do this we shall rise
We must let the spirit enter
the progress of human evolution the way it really is. Here we must say
the element contained in denominational religion must always be a drag
must seek above all else if we want to achieve genuine spiritual research.
his crude gallows tree. We must consider these things with regard to
social organism that of necessity must arise from the present and into

Title: Natural Science; the Anthroposophical Movement
Matching lines:

surrounding our everyday lives. This is what we must learn to
in such a way that they can say: All this must be true because
about these things, so we must during the examination of
must be asked: What happens in the human soul when it connects
death; murders the soul. This is something which must be
scientific knowledge, and that the soul must experience a
actually lives within it and must not be excluded. As a result
Humanity must learn to understand that only with a real sense
while finding these things uncomfortable, while they must live
Today we must make it increasingly clear: Our friends have
with these things. These things must be done at their allotted
re-strengthening must come. This empowerment must come in such
Every one of us must work together towards the enlivening of
that time would have stipulated how things must work, and the
these must be encountered with real interest. We need to know
such a fact must be recorded. Yet this is a fact and this is
individual strengths we have. We need them. We must be steeped
real, true understanding but we must be clear about how these
said today must be understood until our next meeting, and

Title: Preparing for a New Birth
Matching lines:

the most significant element in life must appear to be
body. The physical body must be set in action for us, as

Title: Spiritual-Scientific Consideration: Lecture 1: Prelude to the Threefold Commonwealth
Matching lines:

dear friends, — and this must be said today and to
trial that we must undergo, a test of that which has been
of ours must not confine itself to the taking in of
year, that our anthroposophical conviction must lead us
further; it must lead us to a better understanding of
is penetrated by the spirit; it must lead as to a better
dear friends, of many things. We must learn the lessons
One must recall today the way in which those persons to
who penetrates into existence must feel. That is the
because it must be said today: It is essential that one
but,of this: of realizing that humanity must learn new
have no reality out are only images in a mirror. One must
happy, when they talk of ideal conditions that must be
all must be realized in Middle Europe. You have these
must be right at all times in the same way. Things have
friends, one must look more deeply into human evolution
Threefold Commonwealth. This threefolding — I must
One must say, my dear friends, that since the spread of
of culture: And then one must think of international
in single instances. One must be able to view the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Spiritual-Scientific Consideration: Lecture 2: Esoteric Prelude to an Exoteric Consideration of the Social Question I
Matching lines:

must use a paradox) physical-spiritual life. You know of
political life, state life. Naturally one must employ all
discrimination must distinguish between phases of ideas
from the outer world. Certainly we must give expression
matters; but one must withdraw into one's self, into
one's soul-life, one must live in oneself. That fact
spiritual Spiritual Science must express it in these
independent inner life must be present in man in order
perceptive organ one must know that) — with that
spiritual-scientific way. Spiritual Science must first of
will create what must be created: relations of Right
at the third, the economic life. Something must be said
very actively you must struggle within yourselves when
considering immortality. We must be much less
must make here, during our life, a new link for the chain
who only thinks of what goes forward in this life, must
since the 15th century that he must now cultivate
way to the threefold social organism: how it must be
organism also must be threefold, with each part centred
However, I said that one must not mistake what is
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Spiritual-Scientific Consideration: Lecture 3: Esoteric Prelude to an Exoteric Consideration of the Social Question II
Matching lines:

must see into the so-called unconscious, or subconscious,
whole we must look for the most important forces of
If such comparisons are used it must at the same time be
it out) I must compare it with the experience that an
Worlds, a man must have so schooled himself that he
natural to him; more and more it must be developed by him
this period mankind must go through in its evolution as a
is what one must discover through spiritual science. It
today. For the crossing of this threshold must truly not
remain in the unconscious. Men must become aware of it,
must develop out of our inner self the power with which
dear friends, this is in our power. We must undertake the
out of whet the time has already brought. No we must seek
World knowledge must first discipline one so that one can
swinging of a pendulum back and forth. Man must seek
One must study Ernst Mach, and then become acquainted
ideas then we must not search, as Mach and Avenarius did,
world-conceptions. We must turn to the new structure, the
of social order must come, since from now on man, as he
is crossing the threshold. The external social order must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Spiritual-Scientific Consideration: Lecture 4: Pedagogy, from the Standpoint of the History of Culture
Matching lines:

need. But one will only be able to comprehend what must
speaks in these times as one must on an anthroposophical
education. We must above all things gain a knowledge of
and our perverted educational life; this knowledge must
what we must see today, what we must realize above all
things. Today we must drive out of men's souls from the
action. We must fill our souls with what can really
inspirit us when we speak. We must find a way to
make the heart speak behind the lips. We must find a way
alluring us from the earnestness of reality. We must put
us from our evils. We must look within ourselves, within
it is a question of spiritual life. Our education must
may call it today. It must also find a way out beyond the
one must learn the dear significance. This is the true
We must ask
What must
be done, my friends, must be done out or reality. For
comparison without resorting to phrases, one must present
is another reason why this nonsense must be uprooted,
When I confront a machine I must confront it as a whole
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Esoteric Studies: Lecture I: Cosmic Aspect of Life Between Death and New Birth
Matching lines:

correct, still to all this may be added that which must be said
we must seek the substance of our soul — for we cannot
has to occur for man because it is what really must happen to
conscience” must cooperate as servants of the spirits of
we are concerned here. And it must be said that those people
time the inhabitants of the earth must gain here on earth an
understanding of the Christ impulse, and must keep this impulse
Christ. And we must take so much strength with us from
is fitting for us men, we must have the Christ impulse as a
necessary: in the sphere of Mars, we must have the possibility
Mars-sphere, we must consider the following. A great decisive
bring nothing spiritual, we must of necessity experience this
we must gain a living experience of them. — The
existence, a possibility must be created to have, with
progress of souls on earth: that these souls must
familiar with it, we must at the same time have hours when we
follow Edison, we must be able to become quietly, in our
the Buddha. Thus every human being must be able to feel even if
forces are gathered which man must acquire in order to be able
spheres, those forces he must extract from the forces which
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Esoteric Studies: Lecture II: Establishment of Mutual Relations Between the Living and the So-called Dead
Matching lines:

on earth must naturally often look back from the spiritual
learned, I know that this soul must be on earth as she was
dead, — we must send our thoughts to them —
— this must be the task of any educator — to
them. In such cases one must call on everything for help; and
right moment. One must try, for instance, to develop a kind of
always must be rightly understood, will not be a mere theory.
finds that the souls who for a certain time after death must
subjected to that which such souls must do. Let us look at the
world penniless and must hire out as a servant, must do menial
unscrupulous souls must be active in the preparation of such
these spirits of sickness and misfortune. Karma must be carried
until the Venus evolution. Souls must not fall prey to
decision of the Higher Hierarchies that this must not happen.
we have what those souls must do who depart early. Strange
in council. Because men must be free, they are given the
the darkness. We must seek this light in order to find our way
forgotten. One must remind the souls of that which they have
we must not merely find pleasure in the ideas which Spiritual
must feel the spiritual power which it must derive from the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: The Experiences of Sleep and their Spiritual Background
Matching lines:

ordinary means of knowledge, must, on the other hand, endeavour to
Knowledge, I must portray it as if it were experienced consciously. I
stage of sleep, anxiety. Into this anxiety must flow power man has
refreshment. We should have to despair of science if we must insist
our solar system. If we must say for the day-time: the white
then we must say for the night-time: there revolves in us a copy of
cosmic experience and because he must pass through this cosmic
wide and comprehensive sense, we must recognise that human
and of which he is not yet conscious. He must receive it into his

Title: Reincarnation and Karma: Lecture III
Matching lines:

case. But certain failures, perhaps just those that must be called
artificial, it fascinates us, gives the impression that it must,
what must happen? We must make compensation for the affront, we must
place into the world a counterbalancing deed, we must discover some
environment. We must far rather assume that there too our karma is at
those that really do shed light upon it, must be acquired slowly and
tiresome to think that all this must be a matter of knowledge slowly
cherish the belief that it might possibly be so, investigation must
warning must be added to what has been said to-day. The genuine
I am sure it must be reassuring to know that the communications made
We, however, must realise that by gaining closer knowledge of life we

Title: Reincarnation and Karma: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

of view must exist in order to make it possible for Anthroposophy to
spiritual world must be taken into account is, of course, the
starting-point of anthroposophical conviction, and this must always
anthroposophical circles themselves it must be realised that what
what must be the aim of true Anthroposophy.
speak in concrete detail about how Anthroposophy must penetrate into
the question that must exercise every soul who is able to look even a
doing. But the world must be made to realise that it is the mission
being comes into the world, his powers and capacities must, after
conclusion, every human being must be treated as if he were a kind of
and karma than the principle that a man must be remunerated, must
overnight! That cannot be. But men must become alive to the thought
a world-order in which it is held that there must be a direct
Naturally the prevailing conditions must remain, to begin with, for
realise that what can, nay must, ensue from recognition of the idea
degree. It must also be said that the connection between what man
about. And these different conditions must be the result of the
realised that something quite different must run parallel with the
pendulum which must have rotated. This experiment, which afforded the
the truths of reincarnation and karma must take equally firm
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Occult History: Lecture 1
Matching lines:

by the soul, which at many points must be willing to listen
and working with set purpose behind him. But we must familiarise ourselves
let us say, into the Egypto-Chaldean epoch — but it must be the
before the thousand. years preceding the Christian era we must reckon
Egyptian epoch we must change our whole way of studying history: instead
as the age of the Heroes — we must now apply a different criterion
as their instruments. We must have These spiritual Individualities always
through higher laws, must be explained in the following age through
Thus we have to do with one who in the real sense must be called a god-man.
have this consciousness, but you must undergo all that I had to experience
knowledge in the occult sense must train himself to feel as if he were

Title: Occult History: Lecture 2
Matching lines:

deeds to stream down from higher worlds into our world. We must realise
physical world, they must make use of the physical human being —
evolution of humanity. But it must not be imagined that this downpouring
ideas must he ignored. — This reminds one again of the bitterly
include everything that must still be withheld from their daughters.
took place during this period, must say to himself: Suppose the deeds
Chaldea, in ancient Babylonia. But we must now also observe from the
race. That again is what the facts tell us! It must be kept strictly
the world around us; nevertheless it must be grasped in order fully
shows, however, that this is so; and although spiritual research must
of our civilisation, nevertheless the truth must be faced fairly and
old myths, we must investigate their occult background. Behind this
Helen, who was carried off to Troy by Paris. We must realise that there
For we must think of the Oracles exactly in the sense I have indicated.
his normal faculties. And now let us picture vividly how Gilgamish must
treated with great earnestness, there must be no unlawful play of fancy,
great inaugurator of ancient Egyptian culture, it must be said that
must be regarded as the Babylonian culture inaugurated by Gilgamish,
work through Gilgamish, and it is in a Fire-Spirit that we must see
science. It must therefore be said that despite all materialistic ideas
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Occult History: Lecture 3
Matching lines:

But we must now take account of the fact that during the first, the
that this ancient Indian culture must be attributed to a kind of activity
by dint of our own activity, we must, to begin with, be able to acquire
in a purely human way; but then we must not remain at the point where
ourselves must be carried upwards md interwoven into what is still to
come; we must take the direction upwards, as it were, to what is to
of how in spiritual matters we must distinguish between the objectivity
form of a certain picture. We must not conceive these pictures to be
the spiritual reality itself; nor must we ascribe direct objectivity
must not for that reason assert that the objective revelations themselves
the soul. We must distinguish between the objectivity of that content
our outer impressions must be directed upward to the spiritual. But
We fulfil it only when we are conscious that these impressions must be
We must regard everything that we can learn about the laws of natural
biological, physiological, psychological laws must be related to something
to add: that epoch is now over; we must accept what springs from it,
masterpieces. In looking at them we must be able to forget that the
must not see this self-contained being only, but standing behind him
an individuality of a higher Hierarchy. That is the picture we must
their individualities back into the past. From Alexander we must go
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Occult History: Lecture 4
Matching lines:

and must be attained in ever-increasing measure during the coming centuries
themselves and we must rather concern ourselves with what can be learnt
But at the same time it had to be shown that the personality must first
The fourth and the fifth civilisation-epochs must be lived through before
has come down to our own times, as can be demonstrated. We must, however,
to creep. We must learn to have respect for the profound knowledge of
everything that must be incorporated into civilisation for the needs
of number in world-happenings. I must emphasise that the application
But we must remember that
who is inspired but is no longer aware of which secrets must be kept

Title: Occult History: Lecture 5
Matching lines:

understand the historical life of mankind on our earth, we must always
its totality. We must not, to be sure, take an average Persian when
of the twelve forces must reveal itself also in its microcosmic form, in
human intelligence; that is to say, it must come to expression in the
the spiritual-scientific outlook. And such indications must
It must however be emphasised
must reveal some similar phenomenon. And as from a distance things can
he must direct his gaze outwards, he must observe Nature and investigate
historical development, we must take stock of conditions
must keep well in mind that in all such matters there are again other
there happenings fully, we must also take into consideration that such
ago, to say: There is a group of souls who must be prepared in order

Title: Occult History: Lecture 6
Matching lines:

we can surmise that it must be one in which the principle of the universal-human,
Greek civilisation, the following must also be said. It was preceded
entirely within himself, it must not be thought that such things need
Powers, just as now the still higher freedom which must be prepared
We must therefore realise
grandeur of there unparalleled figures, we must conceive that these men
for it must be realised that the full greatness of what lived in Aeschylus
appears as though in forms of logic — indeed, here one must say
soul if the question is asked: What must have become of Southern Europe,
is how we must learn to feel history, for what is offered us in the
that must be especially cultivated, this or that must be the main consideration.
Stoics ask: What must man do in order to become wiser in the practice
an element that may be described as follows. — Men ask: How must
What picture, then, must
times — or, we had better say, pre-Grecian times — how must
of Beings of the higher Hierarchies They must have said to themselves
must be recognised as taking precedence of the physical man and the

Title: Karmic Relationships, VI: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

sublimity of all these works, but it must be remembered that they are
must look up to the Moon existence with feelings deepened through
may have been here ten years ago must not imagine that the same
the poet says: “this you must be, you cannot escape from
You must not allow the heat or cold to pass through you as it might
destiny and we must not succumb to the superstition that illnesses
kind of activity it must abandon the paths it has been taking during
these last ten years; it must cease to concern itself with
externalities, must penetrate to inner, spiritual realities.
The School of Spiritual Science to be established in Dornach must
have this esoteric character, and so must the Society as a whole in
order to maintain the spiritual life it needs. It must throw off the
leadership of the Society must be more and more consciously
often said, instead of all this we must emphasise the reality which

Title: Karmic Relationships, VI: Lecture V
Matching lines:

Lessing must certainly have experienced something of the kind
or later the time must come when it is possible to speak concretely
view — which must also become a point of view
There must
study must be to illumine the circumstances of human life and the
political visionary — for that is what he must be called. In an
must unite for life. It turned out to be the happiest and also one of
must be so close and strong that the teacher might not desert them
omits intervening incarnations as women. — You must not
matter of speaking of the karmas of individuals one must always have
matters must be taken with deep earnestness, unmixed with any trace
stronger impulses that must be at work within the Anthroposophical
expression of the fact that esotericism must stream through the
earnestness these things must be studied. If this earnestness is
man and of his destiny, humanity must come to realise that through
mankind must be recognised and known.

Title: Karmic Relationships, VI: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

to answer this question, attention must be called to a cosmic event.
as altogether terrible. But at any rate a man must come to realise which
and you must make compensation! Thereby the plan of karma is laid
ill in one way or another. In soul and spirit he must be completely
us what must be done for human beings on the Earth to free them from
to have more precise insight into how karma is formed, we must think
We must see in the shining stars the outer signs of colonies of
to grow wise, he must undergo inner development, he must struggle,
acts and human existence. In this respect we must get away from that
sight. Such details must be studied, for, as I have often said, it is
things must be studied with a free and wide outlook. When I say to
strange — as it certainly will — we must
is usually believed. In order to understand it, our thoughts must not

Title: Lecture: The Tasks and Aims of Spiritual Science
Matching lines:

yourselves of this if you ponder it well. The younger members must
this recapitulation; and the Theosophical Movement must be taken
being presented. And it would be wrong to assert that one must merely
essential fact. We must in our own lives put to the test the
repeating the phrase: That must be taken on trust! Accept as little as
first thing upon which stress must be laid.
effort, it demands thought and work. It means that one must really set
must be trained too, even if it is irksome, in order that we may be in
wrong from every point of view. For we must consider the age in which
epoch when conscious thought must be developed, just as in the
Theosophy must now, at this time, be brought down out of the
super-sensible world and must make its appeal to the reasoned thinking
Here it must be emphasised that to have something, and to be conscious
This fact you must have clearly before you, that the old clairvoyance
is there for people to remember? A self-contained ego must be there in
out of it. You must put it in the soil and let it grow, you must let
entirely their own and must lead up to what is possible in the higher
But if we are not thinkers, the revelations must seek other forms,
but we must at the same time be aware that a thinker has a different.
clairvoyance must indeed be of a pictorial character in its early stages,
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Deeper Education: Lecture I: Gymnast, Rhetorician, Professor: A Living Synthesis
Matching lines:

have reached a point at which we must cultivate the synthesis
having to describe so dryly what you must know in this regard
and must receive in your hearts' minds [die
may again get distorted, as happens with so much that must be
said. It must not be distorted. The teacher should simply
away into symbolism, but the connection with the cosmos must be
experienced. The melody must really be “spoken”
scorn. What you must do is to create a relationship to the
to the children in a living way. We must begin at this point
the caterpillar must develop its being in the air; the most
we need above all else in our work as teachers. We must relate
our teaching is boring there must be something wrong with it,
These are things that really matter, and we must realize, my
of gymnast, rhetorician, and professor. We must overcome the

Title: Deeper Education: Lecture II: Forces Leading to Health and Illness in Education
Matching lines:

that they cannot have yet as children. We must impart such
must be imparted to him through education. But the answer
with a certain heaviness. This heaviness must be
we must deal in the classroom. Now, it is essential for you to
the higher grades we must take into account the impossible
lose sight of our own goal, and therefore we must work to
fact must be faced and understood. We must realize that we
must become conscious of this, but conscious of it inwardly,
hearts we must be able to become conscious of it. This is
the last three or four centuries. It is this that we must find
being must evolve, must be brought to a higher level, but this
reality of what education means. Education must have something
nature of the human being must permeate each individual
in the test tube. There astral forces above all must be at
forces, however, that we must know in any substance if we wish
rhythmic activity that must be considered if we wish to
breathing, as teachers we must bring the next higher stage into
to heal something, however, and if healing is needed there must
be illness. If that is so, walking, grasping, digesting must be
becoming ill. We must counter it through a higher process of
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Deeper Education: Lecture III: A Comprehensive Knowledge of Man as the Source of Imagination in the Teacher
Matching lines:

afternoon, I would like to add the following. You see, we must
is the one in which he moves his limbs. Now we must pose the
to say to ourselves that it is the spiritual itself that must
physical, into action. Our leg must be moved by something
— that is to say, something purely spiritual — must
must be directly active. Materialistic science simplifies
move by magical means. We must not limit our gaze to the
physical body with the movements of man but must turn to his
this knowledge must be created a feeling of responsibility and
a true consciousness of one's purpose as teacher. We must
during the period between the change of teeth and puberty, must
vital knowledge than it is otherwise, but the knowledge must do
its work, the knowledge must live, and the faces of the
lives and weaves in our time. Gandhi says that he must of
clear that I must of necessity condemn you. It is obvious that
of humanity. Clearly, however, British law must in all severity
condemn you I must.” Gandhi's sentence was six
duty to continue what he must define as criminal in face of
must keep this clearly in mind, because it is intimately bound
usually less obvious and startling. We must achieve first,
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part III: Stuttgart, 2-17 (20)-'13
Matching lines:

One must always meditate these three words with a feeling of the deepest
piety in one's heart. And then we must get to the point where we're
conscious of our divine I; it must as it were be born in us again:

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part III: Stuttgart, 5-18-'13
Matching lines:

esoteric must learn and that the Gods have written into world
reproduce and would die out. So a real esoteric must look up to the
reverential thanks and must tell himself that he owes his

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part III: Stuttgart, 11-23-'13
Matching lines:

thoughts; it must bring us to self-knowledge — that we've
What we must
of this clear to ourselves, for we must see Lucifer and Ahriman
when we must try to form spiritual organs of clairvoyance in us and
don't dry up and waste away. We must slowly and gradually grow into

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part III: Stuttgart, 3-5-'14
Matching lines:

everyone who's on a path of esoteric development must gradually
spiritual world. We must learn to rethink, as it were,
and our whole life of feeling and perception must also become
must become aware that all space around us is filled with spiritual
world we must transform our whole thinking through esoteric
May what must seem like nothing to you
(I must

Title: Reappearance/Christ: Lecture IV: Mysteries of the Universe: Comets and the Moon
Matching lines:

only with a tiny corner of the world, and we must take time to learn
our time. We must bear clearly in mind that the designations
everywhere in the cosmos, but one must understand how to discover
the apes who stand near to him, we must say that, although the ape
made a hash of it ... and that is the point. One must have insight
into the relative weight of a truth! We must feel the importance of
Hence, we must see cometary existence as the cosmic archetype of the
the whole universe, we must not simply think of one member side by
evolution. The comet has remained at this stage, but now it must
(one cannot always present everything; one must not write one book but
true, there must be proof of something like compounds of carbon and
Above all, we must become conscious of how the contrast
expressed in comet and moon works upon the human being. We must not
man and woman in humanity, because we must be clear that masculine
complicated. We must realize that the masculine-feminine contrast is
incarnation he must use this masculine brain! The masculine brain is
use a masculine brain. The masculine brain must be trained much more
must be correspondingly transformed. If the I is to think differently
there must also be something that changes the outer expression of the
for materialistic thinking, we must say that in 1835 Halley's Comet
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Reappearance/Christ: Lecture V: The Reappearance of Christ in the Etheric
Matching lines:

understand how this new impulse must work only if we consider the
repetitions must be examined, after all, in detail; they must be
must cultivate itself further. It could never have entered human
We must understand quite clearly to what extent this was
however. We must go a long way back if we wish to find something
scientific contemplation of this matter, one must adhere strictly to
Abraham. We are moving toward this age of Abraham, and it must and
We must make clear to ourselves that two things might
that such clairvoyant faculties, as natural faculties (we must
must perform a particular deed repeatedly. He must, above all,
thinking that knowledge of the spirit must come into the world so as
earthly existence must occur that after the victory over death the
sphere. When, therefore, the human being becomes clairvoyant, he must
risen from the dead,” he must have said to himself. After Paul
between death and a new birth; they must be acquired here on the
physical plane and must be carried with one into the life between
There are faculties that must be acquired on earth, as
nothing is on the wrong track. We must acquire faculties here that we
events, must be acquired here on earth. Those human beings who
Anyone who has deaf ears, however, must wait until a subsequent
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: True Nature: Lecture II: The Second Coming of Christ in the Etheric World
Matching lines:

Understanding of how this impulse must work is possible only when we
these systematic repetitions in the course of human evolution it must
must be investigated in detail and confirmed by spiritual research.
We must, however, clearly understand in what way this denoted an
this subject from the spiritual-scientific point of view it must be firmly
will appear if men prove capable of understanding it. It must,
desire, will have the new, natural clairvoyance. A distinction must,
must be brought into the world to prevent what is coming from
that world; they must be acquired on the physical plane and carried
faculties which must be acquired on the earth, for we have not
deaf ears to this knowledge must wait until a later incarnation to
acquire the faculties that must be acquired here on earth in order
must then grow on to a spiritual understanding of these things,
realising that through Spiritual Science they must learn to
We must come to realise that in the future the most important events
must be sought, not on the physical plane but outside and beyond it,
just as Christ must be sought in the spiritual world when He appears
We must
their path must be reversed, that a spiritual life must begin, then,
have ears to hear and eyes to see, must be described as denoting the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part II: Stuttgart, 12-24,31-10
Matching lines:

esoteric feeling of responsibility must become keener; we must
We must

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part II: Stuttgart, 12-31-10
Matching lines:

sensible esoteric will tell himself that he must first create order
Even in normal development some things will arise of which we must
is very harmful for an esoteric. Alcohol must definitely be avoided.
We must tell ourselves that when we've gotten up the courage to
tread the esoteric path we must make a jump over an abyss. We must
Christian is a distant ideal that he must constantly try to attain.
worlds to make the damage good again. For what is ruined must be

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part II: Stuttgart, 1-2-11
Matching lines:

We must
take esoteric life seriously, and so an esoteric class must always be
delusions about themselves. We must especially pay attention to
become aware of yet. Then as esoterics we think that we must tell him
We must
sense life. And so an esoteric must constantly watch himself, and it

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part II: Stuttgart, 2-20-12
Matching lines:

goes to an esoteric school must take his age into account. But since
physical body as something that belongs to him. But he must already

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part II: Stuttgart, 2-22-12
Matching lines:

esoteric must look at life with alert eyes from his firm, immoveable
esoteric must regard Kun Hung Ming's book, China's
paradise of spiritual worlds. We must now revoke Lucifer's
of a plant, but of a highly developed one. We must get rid of the

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part II: Stuttgart, 2-12
Matching lines:

through concentration and meditation we must fill ourselves with a
incarnations, be it sooner or later. He must eradicate the wrongs
hand, his vices inevitably appear, and here an esoteric must use his
we realize that we have a divine origin and that we must develop
us, and when we're aware of this it must be our duty not to let
stream of development. We must take the unfolding of our spiritual
organs in hand ourselves, we must no longer let ourselves be
led — we must become companions of our leaders. It's a

Title: Esoteric Lessons Part II: Stuttgart, 2-23-12
Matching lines:

sorrows. The meditation must be our last thought that we take into

Title: Truths and Errors: Lecture VI: Errors of Spiritual Research - 2
Matching lines:

be recognised and whose significance must be overcome. One
gift, but his human value must be judged as that of the other
not regard the spiritual as something spiritual; it must be so
just said that it must be defeated. We have said to understand
each other that any egoity of a medium must be extinguished, so
must also blank out his egoity consciously if he faces the
that such souls cannot advance to spiritual beings that must be
can see physical beings with physical eyes. He must be able to
—, you must be able to recognise the human being outside
being must be outside his self and then consider himself in
worlds must be a world process, not a single process. We have
destroys. We must defeat it; we must let forces grow —
frivolously by those who only must familiarise themselves with
of spiritual research. You must have this sensation at first,
can, must and should be pronounced again and again.”

Title: Truths and Errors: Lecture VIII: The Questions of Life and the Riddle of Death - 2
Matching lines:

there just in this chapter, and there one must say, as good and
understanding the misfortune because we know that the soul must
spiritual researcher. One must be a spiritual researcher to
recognise, as long as we are still imperfect, that we must
will know that we must experience our guilt in this and in
the world. In view of this fact, you must not be surprised

Title: Curative Eurythmy: Lecture 8
Matching lines:

basis for the correct understanding of curative eurythmy must be taken
of visible speech. We must recognize that two components work together
die from water than from alcohol. Even the statistics must concede this:
A, for example, must be repeated a number of times in succession. By this
one must be able to do it in a specific manner in a particular case.
by inhalation. You must take inhalation into consideration here in its
entirety. In examining the in-breath, we must to begin with follow its
must be studied in such a way that respiration is taken into consideration.
nourishment, so to speak, you must direct your attention principally
to supporting the thrust that accompanies the inhalation; you must add
and one must focus one's attention there, where irregularities in teething
a fact that one must awaken in oneself a feeling for the artistic in the
dynamics of the human being as a whole. One must develop an intuitive
with the radiating element. You must judge, by how much strength must
be applied, how many times the sound must be repeated. Let us say, for
deformation, I must then first prepare the ground with consonantal
taken place. In short, one must approach the matter as untheoretically
as possible; one must discover, solely out of knowledge of the human
Wesenheit”) in the human organism. These two dynamics must be
functioning heart, something must be done for it. Yes, but if one were
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Inner Nature of Music: Lecture V
Matching lines:

must be pointed out that all the concepts used in other areas of life
must first be created in the given physical world. This caused people
we must understand the entire tone experience in man more deeply. I
must repeat that all concepts come into confusion in encountering the
importance merely as a reflecting apparatus. We must actually say
that regarding the musical experience, we must view the human being
three-fold organization and find that we must say: nerve man,
not the significance we must ascribe to it in other conditions of the
one that must reach beyond ordinary concepts — can illustrate
come to a region where we actually must stand still. The experience
through the etheric and astral bodies to the seventh. We must now
arrive at the next higher octave. We must say, as it were: man
have, to feel, our own self once more. You must take all these
felt it; in order to express it, we must word it like that —
possible extent, but not yet the actual c. This must still be
appreciation must be based on the appreciation of the fifths; this is
must be offered the child in the way of music thus will be adapted
too. The physical body, however, must push upward into the etheric
We must leave music behind when we think, because tone begins to

Title: Lecture: Inner Nature of Music: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

they are quite fragmentary and incomplete and must be elaborated
interval of the fifth. Naturally, he must experience something empty
emptiness in the fifth and must fill it with the substantiality of
earlier ages, the relationship of musical man to his instrument must
we must take the other aspects of music into consideration if we wish
peculiar thing about the musical element is that neither must it
directions it must be contained. The musical experiences must take
place within the realm situated between thinking and willing. It must
must not penetrate thinking, but it streams toward it. This streaming
toward willing. It must not penetrate the realm of willing, however;
it must restrain itself, as it were, and this is accomplished through
comprehends melodies more readily than harmonies. Of course, one must
not take this pedantically; pedantry must never play a role in the
related to the nature of will — man must inwardly activate his
beings, in other words, in the age of introversion. One must seek the
told you yesterday, however, one must forego concepts; abstract
exist. If one wishes to comprehend the musical element, one must
from the intervals into rhythm must be experienced fully by the
orchestra is an image of man; it must not include a piano, however.
actually, in a musical sense, must be overcome. Man must get away

Title: Poetry/Speech: Lecture VII: The Uttering of Syllables and the Speaking of Words
Matching lines:

– through immediate perception. It must be received as a
A sort of religious feeling must always prepare the mood for art. For
when we speak about art we must speak out of the spirit. How can we
not sing: Homer is conscious that he must raise his soul to the
superhuman, the super-sensible; that he must place his words as a
their external sense-reality; logic must not, therefore, intrude
prose sentence we must feel the solid earth under our feet. For the
entire configuration of the verse, he must again make good what is
the poet’s art, must give special attention to what I have
comes from the section “It Must Give Pleasure,” part

Title: Poetry/Speech: Lecture VIII: The Interaction of Breathing and Blood-Circulation
Matching lines:

Two elements must collaborate in a
other words, we must adjust the timing of the verse in the right
speech-formation must ask himself when confronted with a poem: Have
the town must go;
demonstrate here – of how the art of poetry must be traced
of the blood-circulation. It must be felt anew that just as the
foundation of true art – it must be said that this knowledge

Title: Poetry/Speech: Lecture IX: The Alliteration and Terminal Rhyme
Matching lines:

about the art of poetry by means of an illustration. It must,
so to speak, to do penance. We must go through with the transition
and how we must try (in terms of either declamation or recitation)
brother. We must defer more to the genius of the language, rather

Title: Lecture I: Man in the Past, the Present and the Future
Matching lines:

If we really manage to observe what happens, we must say that we are
We must, however, realize that what we are now describing as the basic
must be observed closely. Now while the sun follows his course through
Take the grain of wheat or rye. It must be planted within the Earth at
farmers must undertake this or that work, or the bulls be introduced
Imaginations and not our ordinary ideas which we must have in our

Title: Lecture II: Man in the Past, the Present and the Future
Matching lines:

must lie in some original sin. Thus at a particular epoch the
the future evolution of the Earth must consist in this Mystery being
lighter he must restore his heaviness by a strong exercise of will.
and other planets. In reality one must say that, for a living,
must, to put it mildly, be called a fool!
activity of Angels. We must always keep our eyes on the reality of
survival which we must try to understand. When we can see past in this

Title: Lecture III: Man in the Past, the Present and the Future
Matching lines:

we have been aware must wait 3 or 4 days before it is fully out own,
present age of freedom we must resolve out of our own free knowledge
into the real nature of the fact. Whereas nowadays Initiation must be
all know. One must really ask what is contained in these dreams, what
to be the house-numbers of Europe. We must make it clear to ourselves
is removed from the real spiritual facts. We must have the
We are living at a time when all sorts of inner conflicts must arise
Golgotha. What we must do is to set our experience of the present in
We must always remember that our existing religious systems originated
moral spheres. The future of mankind — that is what we must
participating in our present culture must have the same sort of
as I have so often explained to anthroposophists, we must resolve by
— the whole man who must be comprehended as including man
order to strive for this there must be an enthusiastic, heart-felt

Title: The Three Fundamental Forces in Education: Lecture
Matching lines:

ways; and we must distinguish accurately between the
educator, in teaching and educating, must pay close attention
reasoning and intellectual powers, and those that must be
year, during which we must work with the forces of authority,
You must not interpret that to mean physical strength and
Therefore, they must be held up earlier, whereas the
fundamental forces by which the teacher-soul must be
them of their perception: that they must have; for they would
the astral body takes after death: then the matters must be
lectures on eurythmy. Here, you see, we must talk to people in
Thus, must be kept in mind to understand what follows.
in man as an attack from within and which must be
into human beings. One must, of course, keep in mind that the
depict that which rises out of the human being, but which must
today. We must recognize, then: attack and warding off.
the sculptor, must work more out of his inner faculties, the
not so powerful as that, but I must express il more radically
must be stopped at the periphery by the movements of the
the world, he is really exposed to things from which we must
and let it permeate me, the feeling arises that I must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture I: The Egyptian period, and the present time.
Matching lines:

characteristic form of architecture! We must exert ourselves mentally
to live solely in that spiritual world. A connecting link must be
formed between this spiritual part and the earthly world; we must form
that these forms can be understood; we must realize that they are not
a whole, then to the pointed arches must be added the folded hands and

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture II: Ancient Wisdom and the new Apocalyptic Wisdom. Temple sleep. Isis and the Madonna. Past stages of Evolution. The bestowing of the Ego. Future Powers.
Matching lines:

We must now sketch in a few words, and bring before your souls, the
We must understand that fundamentally the individual can do very
even dangerously ill, we must not regard this as a sign that Spiritual
We must imagine the sun as a vast etheric body on which
epochs. Our age must give birth not merely to an ancient wisdom, but
but which must work prophetically — apocalyptically — into
ancient wisdom preserved, but our wisdom must be an apocalyptic
wisdom, the seed for which must be sown by us. Once again we have need
completely, we must look not to the past alone, but must study what is

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture III: The Kingdoms of Nature. Group-egos. The Centre of Man. The Kingdoms of Higher Spiritual Beings.
Matching lines:

foundation. At the same time we must remember that if we only use our
and in a still higher degree to the Universe. We must realize that the
extent. We must in the first place consider the planet on which we
beings of the other kingdoms of the earth we must be fully aware that
If we consider the difference between animals and man we must
these ten fingers do not move of themselves, but something hidden must
forth their principles into the physical world. One must not merely
picture this diagrammatically, but must accustom oneself to picture
these egos in their reality. It must be clearly understood that we do
physical and etheric body. We must not conclude from this that the
namely its ego. If we wish to locate the ego of a plant we must seek
egos of animals in the circumference of the earth, we must turn to the
must imagine this entire form as hollowed out, that it resembles a
feeling. They must not be only comprehended intellectually, but must
destroyed by the lower forces it must always be permeated and suffused
body, and who said to him: “Thou must be like unto me when in future
looks up to his higher self, whom he must come to resemble more and

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture IV: The Outer Manifestations of Spiritual Beings in the Elements. Their connection with Man. Cosmic partitions. The Myth of Osiris.
Matching lines:

Higher powers must co-operate to give the directing force necessary
world, and we must realize that three more kingdoms have to be added
What exaltation must fill our souls when we look in thought up to
must flee from him. This was picture consciousness, and had a real
We must not look merely for astronomical facts in such a myth as the
myth of Osiris, but we must see in it the result of the deep

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture V: The sacrifice of the substance by the Thrones, Kyriotetes, Dynami's, and Exusiai. Jehovah and the Elohim, and their co-operative activity in the stages of human Development.
Matching lines:

Now we must try clearly to understand how Jehovah and the Elohim on
ancient Saturn, but you must not imagine that this body looked then
past, you must not imagine that had you been able to observe Saturn
You must not imagine this body of warmth as being uniform or
must realize that even during the ancient Moon period the Sun with its
consequence was that something happened which we must try to picture
leave the study of the further development of the Moon itself. We must
know that in many respects what is opposed to healthy development must
change of consciousness. But we must first speak of another
the world. Reasonably, one must come at last to a point where the
Such a statement ought to be taken quite literally, and we must try to

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture VI: The Spirits of Form as regents of earthly existence. Participation of the, Luciferic beings. The formation of race.
Matching lines:

why the Spirits of Form could not set to work on Saturn we must reply:
principles; it must begin by gradually bringing the astral body under
control; this means that man must learn to control his passions and
We must now try to understand the remarkable function carried out at
intervened. How, then, must we regard their having remained behind?
to receive the Christ Principle. We must clearly understand that the
must answer, “He received something which could come to him only

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture VII: Animal forms -- the physiognomical expression of human passions. The religion of Egypt -- a remembrance of Lemurian times. Fish and serpent symbols. The remembrance of Atlantis in Europe. The Light of Christ.
Matching lines:

We must not, however, imagine that all the animal forms we see around
We must clearly understand that from the Lemurian epoch to the middle
In order to complete our preliminary studies we must first glance into
we must select the form of the fish. This is the form which remained
this condition may be compared with that of sleep. Now we must clearly
In order to understand this we must keep one thing in mind: when the
planet to be formed, but upon Venus and Mercury. These beings must be
We must clearly understand that if everything contained in later
must henceforth try to understand the Spiritual Power which at one
time went forth from the earth with the sun. Man must be able to
receive this Power again as an inner spiritual force; he must

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture VIII: Mans connection with the various planetary bodies. The earth's mission.
Matching lines:

like ourselves, but we must bear in mind that on the ancient Moon
embodied in the earth man must become more and more mature through
What is this Christ-Principle? Before we can know what it is we must
love. Beings must be separated from each other so that love may be
regardless of material foundations, must pass from soul to soul, from
this is the case it must also be connected with all the planets

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture XI: The progress of man. His conquest of the physical plane in the post-Atlantean civilizations. The beginning and up-building of the 'I am.' The chosen people.
Matching lines:

We must conceive of everything in the world as graded; that just as
that we must think of man in that ancient period as being in such a
relationship of man to the universe we must try to form a conception,
We must now picture the further development of man from this
We must picture to ourselves that the condition of human consciousness
We must keep before us the fact that man was descending more and more
sense of freedom. We must picture this state of feeling vividly, for
who must be sought within man's innermost being. This conception,
which was the basis of this ancient civilization, that man must lose
within that personality. We must try to understand the mood of this
appearance, but a reality which must be taken into account.
gradually learnt during the earth's development? We must first look
you must wait and which we can only indicate: this is the coming of
symbolically, only too much stress must not be laid on such things;
they must be accepted generally, partly as truth and partly as
Now, we must clearly understand that everything that has to be
specially striven for in the world must proceed from strong impulses;
Christ as being indeed acquainted with Him, but we must look on them

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture X: The reflection in the fourth epoch of mans experiences with the ancient Gods and their way of the Cross. The Christ-Mystery.
Matching lines:

We must not think that such processes did not have corresponding
In order that we may understand the entire human being we must take
Rome; we must now inquire as precisely as possible into his destiny
being. Only think how he must continually inhale a certain quantity of
condition. This is how we must understand what is contained in the

Title: Universe, Earth and Man: Lecture XI: The reversing of Egyptian remembrance into material forms by way of Arabism. The harmonizing of Egyptian remembrance. The Christian impulse of power in Rosicrucianism.
Matching lines:

mind the Anthroposophical principle which lays down that we must put
they must work together for the whole body corporate.
men will organize themselves voluntarily. They will say: One must do
this, the other must do that. Division of work even to the smallest
say: I must undertake a part of the work of humanity, and leave
universe working from one civilization to another, you must make
science can enter into it, but to do this men must devote themselves
this came about we must glance briefly at the way
returned to a central point, where it received reinforcement. We must
material acceptance of the world. These two must be united —
separate ways, but already in our age men feel that they must again
the striving for initiation — must find fulfillment.
late product, that true initiation comes only from the East, we must
further. The matter must be gone into more deeply than is usually
perished through the enjoyment of too much pork; this must not be taken
conceptions, but people must understand the esotericism of such
We must keep in mind the fact that no negation has passed the lips of
What we call “future” must always be rooted in the past;
future. The purpose for the future must be in accordance with the
Through an ever deepening knowledge man must learn how better to
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture I
Matching lines:

experts as they are called. But a change must come into the
often extremely abstract, must die out, and quite new
scientific combinations must arise. This will meet with great
does indeed aim to be of a universal nature, must work
precisely in this direction. It must make it its special
universal space. Certain astronomical facts must perforce be
presenting scientific facts which is customary nowadays must
statements must be made at first purely as results of
friends. We must take up our position from the standpoint of
consciousness. We must say to ourselves: The manner of
15th year must develop certain soul-forces, while in another
must develop an activity of soul and decide for himself. Then
inside out, when I turn the inside to the outside. One must
vertebra of the spinal column. You must turn the tubular bone
terms. And yet I must do so, and I beg the audience,
situation we must alter. If not, our sciences will fall into
Thus we must think of the cell
the other pole of what is seen in Astronomy. We must, in a
they reveal successive stages, and we must then follow the
utmost abstraction. It is reality to say: We must strive for
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture II
Matching lines:

must then be turned to account in quite a different branch of
that Astronomy must be linked with Embryology. It is
that there must come about a regrouping of the sciences, for
must pursue in these lectures. What you will find as proof
we must take a good deal simply from observation in order to
form certain preliminary ideas. We must first build up
Earth's axis itself must move in order to keep pointing to
— which indeed must be assumed — namely the
astronomical science? We must then ask further, turning the
reality. It must therefore be understood from the outset
must not be regarded as quite apart from man, but must be
phenomena with the human being, when I said that we must see
conditions. We must here bring together quite elementary
the true Sun-life (you must not only look for the Sun-life in
itself. Then we must take up another indication, which
must have a connection with the three-fold being of man.
Poles, this yearly course must be connected in some way with
with the movement of the Moon. Nor must it be overlooked that
little must it be overlooked — only people do not make
must it be overlooked that as a matter of fact, man's life of
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture III
Matching lines:

that stream towards us from all sides, must be sought for
within our bodily organism. The organism must in a certain
between Earth and Cosmos. We must pay heed to a phenomenon
not only quantitatively, but qualitatively. We must be able
thing which we must practice in the development of our ideas,
Thus we must
human reproduction we must relate certain ideas referring to
Thus a new science of Astronomy must be
built upon a spiritual-scientific basis. It must be evolved
picture taught in the Schools. But we must understand all
past. We do not want to return to the older ideas; we must
circle, for it must use an inner impulse in order continually
life must be employed in the radius-vector is continually
it a little quaintly You must take care all the time that you
ellipse must be continuously in the right relation to the

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture IV
Matching lines:

We must,
that breathing must have the same causes in man as in the
animal, or again, that the ignition of a piece of wood must
shedding light the same causes must surely underlie the light
causes must underlie the movement of the stone and the
his third Law, quoted yesterday — it must be said that
like, which we must simply omit if we only want to hold to
It must be
All this must be borne in mind. Modern man is taught from
concepts in this particular field, — we must first form
begin with, is a concept which we must examine. The planets
of observation. And yet, in the very forming of them we must
the whole. We must be clear, too, that the paths of the
man. We must go back again and again to the reality.
move in ellipses’. I must modify the concept and say:
bring us to a rigid concept which we must immediately modify
concept we deduce in the first instance must afterwards be
the mutual inclination of the planes of the orbits, must
activity. It must be connected in some way with the living
we come to something else, to which we must pay special
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture V
Matching lines:

must today insert a kind of interlude, for we shall then
— when we must come to a standstill, as it were, and
totality of the celestial phenomena, we must no longer
represented. Precise our most ardent wish must be renounced
the in the further course of these lectures, what must be put
I must put
point where we must recognize that the world is different
see that there must be something which preceeds the
said, must be presumed to have gone before this
what goes before this has to be taken fro granted. We must
beginnings of which we must leave vague and unexplored; then
explained how we must first distinguish those functions and
the human organism; and how again we must recognize the
must find our way back to the macroscopic aspect. Otherwise,
learning to understand man in this threefold aspect we must
But we must
must remember that the brain is in fact floating in cerebral
must not be misunderstood, it is only used to characterize
invasion of the metabolism by the outer world, we must admit
Not only must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture VI
Matching lines:

in the realm of embryology on the other. We must hew out a
the evolution of mankind on Earth we must surely find
‘wolf’ must be something real.
surely not deny that there must be some connection between
must assume that there is some connection; what it is in
ourselves have inherited from the Graeco-Latin Age. We must
come about in India until a must later time, when in more
must conceive that the change which has taken place since the
Something must have happened as regards the mutual relation
must find our way from what is merely calculable into quite

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture VII
Matching lines:

spiritual scientist one must educate oneself to look at
this and from what was given yesterday, I must again
reality of this domain we must being by forming these two
him so. And to this end we need to know man; we must be able
But we must
— in Kizchhoff's way. Before doing so I must however
such things, leaving out many an intervening link. I must
knowledge of the mutual relations of Earth and Sun we must
what emerges in man and in the animal we must derive the

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture VIII
Matching lines:

conclusion we must still pursue the rather subtle course I
the 11th and 15th January. We must arrange the times by
that we must adopt a different method. We have to take our
the Universe with his senses; we must take man as a whole in
celestial space may be. These are the kind of things we must
now living. Before the last Ice-Age, we said, there must have
What must it
then have been like for man? In the first place he must have
and in his inner conditions man must have been far more
man was given up to the outer world must have been somehow
must in other words have experienced periodic alternations in
saw was then in process of development must alternately have
springs in each succeeding year. I must image something or other
the trunk. I must say to myself — what this plant here
is growing on, must somehow be there in the trunk too (on the right).
In other words there must be some element of the Earth —
not belonging to the Earth; rather must I regard it as a
taking the simple facts — you must admit that it is
the main we must admit that in the animal no further
could pursue them to the end, we must deduce the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture IX
Matching lines:

point in our studies from which we must proceed with extreme
which are at all justified, we must first see whether it is
is what he is, we must first of all gain a clear
understanding of man himself. We must understand the picture
must know what a foreshortening means, and so on, in order to
through man, we must first be clear about man. Now it is,
are probably already well acquainted, but which we must
To be on the right path, we must therefore concern ourselves
the hyperbola, the curve of constant difference, and we must
Here, we must picture the
form a continuous mental picture of this curve, what must you
branch as independent of the other, I must go out of space; I
with something which shows us that in some way we must leave
process through, we must go on thinking in such a way that
curve of constant product. There must then be a curve of
the division of BM by AM. We must be able to find different
left of the y axis). What must we do, however, if we try to
another kind of circle, which must be thought of in the other
ask: What must be the locus of a point, illumined from a
fitting into a complicated curve. The quality that we must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture X
Matching lines:

Oken must be modified if it is truly to be applied to man.
which we must have in order to establish the morphological
world. You must consider as related in their influence upon
the inner surface of the tubular bone. These you must see to
belong together. You must regard the world in the inside of
must however be extended to the entire human organism. In one
all the human organs we must distinguish between two opposing
how must you draw the counterpart of this line? You must draw
consciousness, and which we must look for in the
well imagine, indeed we must imagine that the same polarity
consciousness, so to reach any real result, we must look for
what happens in the embryonic life. In other words, we must
just described must be taken into account with the same inner
attempting to explain the embryo we must take these two
magnetism into account in connection with the magnet, so must
must learn to see the relationship which exists in man
‘sphere’. Then you will say: We must distinguish
We must
wish to go further, we must consider various other
must turn our attention to yet another thing.
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XI
Matching lines:

understand, we must leave the animal out of account to begin
we have seen, if we wish to relate Man to the Cosmos, we must
comes to man in a radial direction. Whereas we must assign
this difference, we must relate it, to begin with, to what
illusionary factors (yet after all, we must admit,
comprehensive interpretation of the World-picture we must
emphasised how to this end the form of man must be seen in
must bring in the evolution of man and of mankind. In a word,
well-known to most of you, yet we must call it to mind for
must consider longer periods of time, since in short periods
present form, we must be clear that the form of it changes in
We must
Bear in mind what it must signify that as you go
inner relationships of growth must play their part, not only
certain point you must imagine it transformed; the
must only not fall back again into rigidity of treatment.
fundamental figure. Therefore, to say the least, we must in
our position on the Earth. (We must refer it back to our own
planets must somehow correspond to the whole man; the fixed
move with the Earth (we ,must project this backward, once
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XII
Matching lines:

you must imagine the Lemniscate as such with variable
has constants in its equation, we must think variables. The
we must not be put off my this. The
of it must be so imagined that in the one half
Further we must imagine that from this
loops when in conjunction, their loop-formation must in some
must be when they are forming their loops, that is to say,
inferior planets respectively. We must therefore assign, what
and the metabolism, In other words, we must attribute to the
Somehow therefore we must contrast the relation to man, and
man we must in some way seek what answers to the Sun's path,
Important truths will follow from this, We must conceive,
along the spine of the animal. There we must seek what
A mere comparative morphology will not avail us, for we must
too we shall derive some indication of what must be the
in perspective (for here again we must express it with great
caution). They must be so situated that the one path is
this, we must surely relate the Sun's path itself to what in
path must be radial in relation to the surface or the Earth.
the revolution of the Earth around the Sun must therefore be
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XIII
Matching lines:

before the Christian era. We must therefore assume that among
we must first enter more fully into the one adduced
around the Earth; to comprehend it we must assume the two
the question we must now be asking: Is it the same?
we must put down a number, representing his daily movement
equals the movement of the Sun. We must write y again, and so
bodies; we must go out of it to the centre of the epicycle.
completely. Before the 15th Century we did not do so. I must
sense we must return. Yet how? Kepler still had a feeling of
through the heart. Jupiter, we must admit, spins like a wheel
must look for the way back, — to re-establish once
Kepler did. And to this end we must include in our ambit what
two branches of the forked line, we must put plant and
mineral in simple prolongation, while animal and man must be

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XIV
Matching lines:

our measuring and mathematizing, must take its start from
conceiving the observed facts truly? We must really take it
to heart — we must take knowledge of the fact —
heavenly bodies in celestial space must in some way be
to this question we must once more compare the kind of
reach the truth by scrupulous investigation, must begin by
we now call the distance of the Moon (I must not say, of the
experienced. We must admit however, it is understandable that
then are the ideas we must regain. We have to realise that
We must then
I must imagine this, of course, of very different consistency
the outcome of it, in all reality. We must face the truth: to
of comfortableness, and you must set to work with all the
jump from one point to another and you yourselves must look
Now you must
contrary we must imagine it somewhat as follows. Evolution
Now we must
must be imagined according to what I have told you in these
formations, we must imagine animal-formation going ever
Moreover inasmuch as it is so, we must accept the fact that
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XV
Matching lines:

movements of heavenly bodies, we must relate the picture to
seen. For a true Science we must accept that there is this
the principle of metamorphosis, as we must always do when
But it will not be so if we take our start, as we must do,
opposite poles in man's organization. But we must not think
word. In that we go from one pole to the other, we must adopt
(We must qualify it with the word 'mainly' for there is
what must be needful also when we wish to comprehend the
organization of man. To pass from one to the other you must
of all points through which a point must run, if when
the connection you simply must go out of space. Once again —
you will not be able to remain in space. You must get out of
space. You must get right out of yourself , looking for
what was said before that the metamorphosis must be so
make it still less simple, you must imagine the one line
though it outwardly shows only two dimensions, must inwardly
space at all. Nor must I think of it as a "fourth dimension"
in the conventional sense. No, I must think of it as being,
we have not yet gone for enough. We must go farther and make
secretion of the kidneys, you must realize that what is there
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XVI
Matching lines:

we have gained so far have shown that we must make careful
must differentiate: the apparent movements seen in the paths
the transition from one to the other must be sought for
kinds: those that work radially and those which we must think
must conclude that it is real. Is there anything to indicate
that a given movement must be a real one? I have already
spoken of this. We must distinguish between movements that
relative sense. We must look for a criterion of true
relative movement, we must perceive what the thing moved has
We must in
which I mean, post-natal life on Earth. We must look back
sense, for in fact nothing is inherited, but we must think of
We must now
interpenetrate the subjective conditions of man, we must go
night, but even they, when they do go to sleep, must adopt a
must, as it were, bring the line of their spine into the same
way: To go to sleep, man must adopt a position whereby his
“absolute” must of course again be taken
organization. The metabolic transformation must also be
anything to the purpose, we must bring ourselves into the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XVII
Matching lines:

essential: You must imagine the plane in which I am drawing
Lemniscate which you must have in mind with regard to all
the blood-circulation can be traced in this way. You must
direction we human beings have in waking life. We must be
them with the same sign. We must give opposite signs to the
cancelled-out in man: It must, as it were, be negatived. The
very thing the plant consolidates into itself, man must get
Ourselves we must imagine in a different way. There is our
physically visible growth, but we must think of something
vertical direction. We must imagine that while man no doubt
In this sense we must recognize, which movements are alike in
led to realize that Earth and Sun must be thought of as
surface which is concave must be bent convex, so that the
determined. You must imagine it like this
along this line. But I repeat, you must include the manifold
expect your calculation to come true. You must include in the
geometrical loci all that is really given. So too you must
other to be at rest. We must imagine both to be in movement,
these lectures I must try to give a resume as clear and as
you will find it so. You must admit, it is a rather
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Astronomy Course: Lecture XVIII
Matching lines:

them accordingly. How must we then interpret similar
must be interpreted rather as tending from without inward
point. The Sun must be conceived as a hollowing-out, shall we
start from such ideas as these. You must imagine that in the
some interpretation of the so-called imaginary numbers must
must then have which would enable you to add to positive matter
However, yesterday we saw that the plant must be imagined
the outer plant must naturally be conceived as growing
from above downwards? Certainly nothing visible; it must be
towards the Sun, we must needs think of what grows in the
must go to the totality from which alone it can be
must also have been formed in a surrounding medium;
at the limits of his skin, we must regard him in connection
connection is he to be understood. Such then must be our
with reality. We must therefore admit that if we try to
little. The constants of the curves must themselves be taken
the path. Yet when a certain time has elapsed I must
disqualify it; it is no longer valid. I must make the
must draw such a Lemniscate
I must remember in so doing that I ought really to be
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Social Basis For Primary and Secondary Education: Lecture I
Matching lines:

actually in everything that must be said on this subject, preeminently
understand them — it must constantly strike us what a gulf there is
between what must be called a declining culture and a culture that may be
then lack clarity — we must grasp it in its symptoms. Symptoms are
there exists something that is on the ascent, something that must be
about what I try to accomplish. You must, however, realise how in all
arise? Here I must draw your attention to an essential phenomenon of our
same time what has had its origin in capitalism, which must not
secondary education we must say to these people: Well and good, but with
lecture courses, and polytechnics. But the question must arise: What
matter must be taken far more profoundly than it generally is today.
outgrown the education to be acquired in his family, when to this must be
of children is to be based. Here we must have in mind that whoever is
Knowledge of human nature from the change of teeth until puberty must
in this sense. For this means that the teacher will know: I must help
psychologists . The teacher must know what to give to his pupil if the
must be developed on wha tever establishes us in the social organism.
must, comparatively early, have good instruction in languages, naturally
anomalies as is done today in the grammar school; it must be started in
human faculties must take place at the right time — they have not
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Social Basis For Primary and Secondary Education: Lecture II
Matching lines:

instruction have to be applied in a new way, in order to give what must
the teaching who must rise to the level of the great and all-embracirg
tasks of the age; they must be first to gain insight into the nature of
the forces concealed behind present world events; they must see which
having their roots in our present existence. These matters must be looked
in those who are teachers. Above all, people must become aware that at
impoverishment and the reasons for this must be understood. The principal
been unable to escape; we must, however, escape from it. There are indeed
must be said today, however, for it is of the utmost importance. The loss
excluded everything human; we must retrace our steps and once again
will have to be recognised as a symptom of decline. We must seek within
he is a man and we ourselves are men. It must be understood that, because
must look to the level on which these things can be discussed, where, by
is rather different but, just because this is so, we ourselves must be
teacher must be directed towards the great world phenomena; he must be
especially is something that a teacher must know. Teachers must have
attention on how we must openly and honestly come to a final settlement
be built up nor looked for intellectually, it must be sought in an
this must say: In the realm of economy this is bad, in that of politics
past, there must arise what is to happen in the future.
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Social Basis For Primary and Secondary Education: Lecture III
Matching lines:

concentration to be so thoroughly undermined. What we must begin upon
must be our first object of attack. If we think at all of restoring our
for his particular state of development. Thus, by careful study we must
mathematical concepts, for example, and concepts of physics. Here we must
weekly lessons on these subjects; we must on the contrary put aside a
point of view, we must be clear, for example, at what age pupils should
receive instruction in arithmetic. At that age arithmetic must be the
educational centres had been imposed upon him. We must reflect on such
has been unable to master what must be mastered. Anyone having experience
specialisation should give place to a general dilettantism. The aim must
we must fight this phenomenon if we have any idea of sending into the
to discover social laws and how they must effect the social will of man.
Hence in this sphere the force of all life of spirit is crippled. We must
delicate vibrations is coming to life, the human being must be led
all education must by psychological. To judge from how things are at
mutual interplay of manual labor and work of the spirit, which must in
incomes. We must face these things as they really are. For the
what must otherwise be imposed upon us, not in the course of centuries
the West reveals today above all how alive we must be to all that comes
negotiations. These things today must indeed be faced as plain facts,
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Introductory Words to the First of Four Educational Lectures
Matching lines:

there are so many things which must be done during these days
later, but, as I have said, there are so many things which must
the being of the teacher must be understood in a completely
call your attention to the fact that the teachers must really
when they are formulated in any way must then be expressed
today we think of the education of the young, we must bear in
impulses of the next generation; we must be clear that our
must also be admitted that this is particularly true where the
question, i.e., of his predetermined Karma. This must come
zoologist. It must never be the result of making our Volkschule
sufficiently be borne in mind, that the art of education must
humanity and many things must be common to humanity if an
western man. But we must know how to keep this among those who
are able to understand it; we must understand how to guard it
with a certain sense of trust, and we must know that it is this
guardianship which will make our work effectual. You must know
people if you want to obtain a result. Then we must above all
modern civilization; we must know that there is absolutely
we must as teachers become artists. Just as it is impossible
to work them out as you went along! I must put the following
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Lecture: Philosophy and Anthroposophy
Matching lines:

obstacles which must be overcome if the soul would avoid being swept like a
appear in a natural way upon the path of human life. But they must be
When confronted by them, we must still retain sufficient detachment to be
cognitive value. We must not shrink from really experiencing their nature;
first advancing beyond them. We must seek access to both methods of
organization. Efforts in this direction must be accepted as the rightful
feeling of reality. We must inwardly experience how the results offered us
of Natural Science should give us occasion to make this experience. We must
must have an altogether different significance — a significance for
human life, into which we must inquire. Knowledge of true reality does not
forthcoming in ordinary consciousness, but must be developed. With true
experience of Natural Science and Mysticism, we must admit that another
form of knowledge must be sought in addition to these — a knowledge
that a new consciousness must be developed, issuing from ordinary
are in a position to name the period when it originated (and must have
is to be substantiated by a purely conceptual process, this must be done
wisdom which has been revealed. This portion of the Wisdom must be accepted
subjective cognitional nets; it must have its roots in faith. There had
must be attained by objective conviction, and, on the other hand, whatever
thrusts into the things he must also extract from them. Of the
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Meditative Knowledge of Man: Lecture I: The Pedagogy of the West and of Central Europe: The Inner Attitude of the Teacher
Matching lines:

should be drawn: the teacher must really have a deep feeling for the nature
people today, we must always bear in mind that we are working on the
feelings, the ideas, the will impulses of the next generation. We must be
these reveal themselves quite simply in the choice that must result when
must come about through the individual's ability, i.e.
through his predetermined karma, the laws of destiny. This must follow from
It must never be the result of an elementary school curriculum designed to
teacher training, whereas the two must be different, through and through.
what we cannot sufficiently bear in mind: an art of education must proceed
mankind to do as a community, and this must be so, if there is to be
must have the discretion to keep this in those circles capable of
understanding it. We must know how to guard it, with a certain confidence,
people, if we want to be effective. Above all we must be clear that we
must know that we have nothing whatsoever to hope for from that quarter for
regard we must as teachers become artists. Just as it is quite impossible
at them as we went along. I must put this in the form of a paradox. Your
becoming — this is what must sustain the teacher, for
must quickly cast off our narrower, personal selves like a snake's skin,
around with us. As teachers we must train ourselves to lay aside these
astral out- breathing. Only we must have a certain sense for dynamics, if

Title: Meditative Knowledge of Man: Lecture II: The Three Fundamental Forces in EducatioN
Matching lines:

unfold in quite different ways. We must distinguish accurately between the
the female organism) must also be given our close attention in education
not retarded before the fourteenth year. This you must not take to mean
human organism, the counter pressure is greater. For this reason they must
— these are the two hidden, fundamental forces that must
this they must have, or they would remain imperfect, not perceiving the
would like to draw your attention to a fact that must have our particular
from within man, what must be warded off continuously, what is damned back
that man may become Man. We must naturally keep in mind that the teachers
is rising up out of man, what must first be transformed to become human.
Luciferic enthusiasm that alone is acknowledged today. In sum, we must come
must work more out of an inner disposition, the musician more out of a
must express this more drastically than it really is, but in this
that something, striving to manifest in the etheric body of man, must be
exposed to things from which we must actually be shielding him through our
sense how unsatisfactory it must always be to make use of conventional
is something we must learn. We have to learn to carry in us something of

Title: Meditative Knowledge of Man: Lecture III: Spiritual Knowledge of Man as the Fount of Educational Art
Matching lines:

that becomes the property of our soul because we have eyes. We must now
organism upwards. And you must now combine this with what I said in the
certain healthy balance must be maintained. If you have too much of it, the
must now do this or that with Johnnie Smith' — or 'This
You have to understand these things. But you must also understand that the
that can throw light on the whole of life, must take place in miniature in
must take in the study of man, understand the study of man through
spirit; the art of education comes about. It must, be a conviction, a frame
must see the human being in such a way that you constantly feel these three

Title: Meditative Knowledge of Man: Lecture IV: The Art of Education Consists of Bringing Into Balance the Physical and Spiritual Nature of the Developing Human Being
Matching lines:

melody in a single tone. You must characterise it from different sides.
means, for example, that the ego must not enter the physical body, etheric
body and astral body too deeply, but that on the other hand it must neither
organisation. That we must avoid. Through our education we must try to
— then one must strive to prevent this tendency to
recollect music, his musical, memory. These are the means we must use when
singing, then we must try to guide him to practise more spontaneous
and metre in the language. As a teacher one must acquire this as an art and
which we must acquire, we have gained the impression that through an
bubble over a little in this way, then we must try something different. And
all this must be integrated within the curriculum. One must start at the
must permeate history with ideas, must show the great connections. Thus,
himself. And they must be part of all that we relate to by becoming aware
nature. It must be admitted that embryological science is rather
other. But it must always be interesting to us to study in a child the
place within the head, you must approach them with the feelings of a
the rest of the organism undergoes, you must feel yourself a musician doing
must take note of the change in the child's manner of moving. These
) and one must
fashion, but even in a less radical form we as teachers and educators must
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Community Building
Matching lines:

presented in the Dornach Goetheanum building must certainly
very profound. But this must pass over, my dear friends, into
Goetheanum, who experienced this profound harmony. And we must
mentioned, we have lost the home that sheltered us, we must all
means must we strive to set up for eternity in our hearts this
The nature of life is such that, when a number of persons must
out of various underlying conditions — and must reflect
to be regenerated, it must not be forgotten, on the other hand,
If we are to participate in the deliberations here, we must
manifested. Must we lightly forget the depths because of
concern with the mere surface of things? This we must not do,
today that must be taken into account. In these two lectures I
Anthroposophy, however, many things must be viewed otherwise
religious renewal. I had to say: “There must be an
their social community.” And this must be quite
must do so for the reason that we are living within the
nature of man, for the reason that our life must become more
must endeavor to present that which is lifted up into conscious
that of naive perception and sensibility. That must be
understand that other element which must play a corresponding
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Community Building
Matching lines:

will occur if we do not say to ourselves: “You must look
what is in the sense world. You must learn to transform your
thinking and your feeling. Just as the dreamer must enter
our ordinary science, and that which must be imparted by
form judgments that must apply to a supersensible world, this
Against this there is a powerful antidote, but it must first be
world. In the spiritual world the soul must be permeated with
the most unqualified tolerance. There one must be able to
sense world. You must admit that one who communicates to his
opponents. He knows that he must have opponents, but he is not
alternative: Either the spiritual-scientist must take in hand
must concern himself with all sorts of things that must draw
done at once — or he must leave to others who have
all, Anthroposophy, this basis must be defended by those
These things must really be viewed with complete objectivity.
Anthroposophical Societies, which must be constituted in the
which older members feel they must keep in their bookcases. But
which we must work, if we wish to establish a right relation to
the world, must be sought for in this way. This spirit should
consciousness of these things must enter into every single
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 1: Evolution and Consciousness, Lucifer, Ahriman
Matching lines:

the way individuals need to face those challenges we must
question we must ask ourselves is whether anything still
thinking. This ancestor said — and I must translate
floating into them during the Old Moon stage. So we must
we must firmly decide not to think in entirely human
terms. We must think beyond anything anthropomorphic, and
the approach we must use if we want to see clearly that
the cultivation of mind and soul that is needed. We must
go entirely by our feeling I, too, must believe that I am
the facts speak for themselves. We must learn to look to
must take our orientation from what the facts have to
of being swayed by our subjective emotions. We must not,
beings must first do it right.
horizontal surface can give and must now ascend again in
moral, ethical terms. We must learn how human life is
it were, a language which tells us that we must once

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 2: East, West, and the Culture of Middle Europe, the Science of Initiation
Matching lines:

the truth must be clearly stated.
We must develop through spiritual science and come to
cultural life. This European culture must provide for the
spirit which must arise in Central Europe will have to
people must have the necessary preparation. Keeping

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 3: Political Empires
Matching lines:

which we must base our actions more real. I am looking
their idea of a god. These things inevitably must seem
given in the mystery cult. This must of course sound
sphere of life. We must expand the time horizons we
that Dante, who after all must be considered a great
We must
devastated public life of today unless we do so. We must
walking the earth in human form. We must therefore
physical thrones. We must acquire the spiritual faculties
the spirit. We must learn to fill the abstract formulas
must become able to face truths that are deeply
disturbing to those who grasp them rightly. We must
that must inevitably lead to ruin, to decline and fall,
be pointed out. We must find a way of making it possible
the earth in the earliest empires. We must find a way in

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 4: Western Secret Societies, Jesuitism, Leninism
Matching lines:

that must inevitably take our present civilization to the
the world, people must first of all give recognition and
interest they muster is still rather superficial, subject
in the wider interest of humanity on this earth. It must
humankind without bias. We must make an effort and become
and must not be opportunists or go for compromise. That
them—must make it clear to them—I mean
two people copulate it must please God to send a freshly
respects—contain things the origin of which must be
must fight, of course, even if we do not want to, against
the writer must have known that there were no Akashic
in his library and so he ought to have known; he must
issue, as it was self-evident that the typesetter must
possessed; that has been lost and must now be found
must not play down this difference. If we do play it down
exists. According to it the faithful must regard their
the spirit of anthroposophy must above all work towards

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 5: How the Material Can Be Understood Only through the Spirit
Matching lines:

certain impulses must be brought into modern civilization
transformed body of the preceding life — you must
become eyes. We must look at the physical world and
intellect must illumine the material world in this way.
These concrete truths must reach as many hearts as
social organism and economic life must fall into decline
your attention to a few things. We must be aware,
change, to adapt to this change. You must properly
must take account of it in everything we say and do. The
important and I must ask you to consider it carefully
my work, but we must be very clear that things are
must be made to see that it does not remain this way. It
spiritual work that has been done and must continue to be
done there is no point to it all. The spiritual work must
years, for decades. This work must be seen as something
human understanding, must be there as well; it is the
impulses of another person, and so on. It must be
basis of genuine truth, surely it must happen that when
moralize. Just for once, however, I really must discuss
undertakings that must not fail, that will have to
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 6: Materialism and Mysticism, Knowledge as a Deed of the Soul
Matching lines:

proper regard must be paid to the gravity of the present
deed accomplished by the human soul. We must come to
the way recognition of the truth must be seen as a deed,
we must keep in mind, even the theosophical school was
must be taken into account and taken positively into
religious confessions must of course attack anything that
is new; they must fight intensely against anything that
brings progress in cultural and intellectual life we must
the present age have brought to light. We must be fully
must be evolved by people who are alive in and part of
progress of humankind we must develop a particular basic
direction. We must develop the feeling that it is utterly
ideas you find yourself in a materialism that must lead
senses. We must therefore develop the feeling — we
the human kingdom, we must not look for anything material
called a phenomenon. We must not allow our fantasy to
in the spirit. That is the feeling we must evolve —
matter; we must rise above such things!’ That is
reality. The search for truth must be based on facts.
must make the search for truth a deed. It must be a
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 7: Materialism, Mysticism, Anthroposophy, Liberalism, Conservatism
Matching lines:

things right essentially means that we must no longer
other hand we must grasp a second, quite different fact.
it must be sought within us, through mysticism. There we
arguments. The materialist is in error and therefore must
logical ideas must be replaced with ideas relating to
science. They must be replaced with concepts that not
want to stress over and over again: we must get beyond
content. This is something we have to learn. We must not
we must look for its reality. Let me ask you this. Would
spiritual science working towards anthroposophy must come
things we see in ordinary life simply must be considered
that is real we must in fact follow something that lies
the one anthroposophy must now follow for the weal of
itself away from the brain. People must make efforts to
they must think those thoughts through. People must make
physical brain. People must tear themselves free. It is
are wrong; but we must face the fact that very many
overcome it because it is right and we must fight against
way in the past Is now finished. We must consider things
come to know about them, must now become reality, why we
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 8: The Opposition of Knowledge and Faith, Its Overcoming
Matching lines:

be known with certainty and must remain a matter of
knowledge and belief poses a riddle which must be solved.
outer science triumph. People must want to use that same
We must want the attitude and approach used in outer
is the historical untruth of the present age. This must
be clearly and firmly understood. It must also be
oneself by the opposite name, as it were. Humanity must
it is indeed in the process of doing so. Humanity must go
procedure used to characterize it in words must be
the progress of humankind, we must get into the habit of
instead one must assume that human beings desire to know
on earth must be seen as the fulfilling of a mission we
approach that simply must come to be widely accepted in

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 9: East, West, and Middle
Matching lines:

the physical basis of our life of ideas, must have
sense organ even when we are dreaming, it must do so to
something of which we must take special note if we want
They demanded that the human being must be perceived and
of the Middle. Goetheanism must be developed further. It
must develop in the direction of soul and spirit. It must
Goetheanism must be extended to become mystery wisdom. It
We must understand it before we can consciously take our
The European Middle therefore must, or ought to, come to
grown old, and on the other hand to the West. It must
future. The culture of the Middle must take its place in
the middle; it must find the energy and the strength to
done today. We must look to the East and look to the West
significance today. And we must take care not to cast any
in an individual such as Tolstoy. We must take our stand
what we must grasp in the present age. On the one hand we
must be wary of past elements reaching across from the
living in this century and on the other hand we must be
must extend beyond geographical boundaries today. It is
working towards Anthroposophy must really stress —
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 10: Transition from the Luciferic to the Ahrimanic Age and the Christ Event to Come
Matching lines:

human evolution which we must know about if we want to arrive at a proper
understanding of current events. We must above all understand where the
civilization, and we must take a good look at it.
the two. First of all, however, we must get a definite idea as to what we
anything in it that is Christian. To regain Christianity we must acquire
provides technical power, the 79 million horses by our side. We must
technology in our next life. The only cure for the nervousness that must
come alive in us it must be able to provide us with insight into the
Surely it must be
‘The destiny of the human race must be determined by human beings
‘The League of Nations must be created, for it will be a great
the two must be brought together, life must be imbued with spirit, and
life must be taken forward to connect with the spirit. The Christ spirit
is the new understanding we must gain for the Christ event; otherwise we
scribes and Pharisees. And there are others of the same kind who must
right way. We must get to the truth! The materialist Pierre Bayle said
must do is to let people enter into an independent life of the spirit.
First of all we must have
must come to accept today, inscribing them deeply in our hearts. If we
that must enter into the impulses of the present age if we are to have a
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

Title: Polarities in Evolution: Lecture 11: Modern Science and Christianity, Threefold Social Order, Goetheanism
Matching lines:

earth must be seen as something that cannot in itself
need to become full human being.’ There must be a
give. This is something we must feel, something that must
of holding. We must be able to ask ourselves in all
must progress to something for which this earth cannot
serve as a guide?’ We must be able to experience,
the earth. We must turn our eyes away from the earthly
earthly realm from beyond the earth. We must look to the
must take hold, with the whole of our being, of what to
begin with is more in form of concepts, of ideas. We must
has come to redeem our humanity. We must come to
this world is made and come to feel there must be
power of Christ within us. And we really must come to
coffined in the tombs we must come to recognize as the
encompass everything, must smash itself to pieces, and
that clear distinction must be made between the life of
must guide us to find the reality of what Schiller
are able to muster to be stored in libraries. It is
our books, for they are the coffins of knowledge. We must
individuality. We must carry it in us. Help will come
Maximum number of matches per file exceeded.

The Rudolf Steiner e.Lib is maintained by:
The e.Librarian: elibrarian@elib.com